Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Animal Kingdom Speer Morgan Human dependency on animals is an often forgotten element of the history of civilization. From the founding of cities fourteen or so millennia ago, people living in settlements have needed animals. I once rode on a bus from Belize through fifty miles of northeastern Guatemala to visit the ruins of the great Mayan city of Tikal, passing along the way small farms and houses where chickens and goats lived in yards, attached rooms, and even the houses themselves. While there are good reasons for today's segregation of livestock and humans—zoonotic infections such as Lyme disease, for example—our industrialization of livestock products seems a less natural extreme than what I saw in rural Guatemala. Human and animal life on earth has quickly and completely changed over a very short time, as has the sense that humans are really in rational control. Over nine-tenths of earth's animal biomass now consists of livestock and humans, with only a few remaining percent being wild. More than 80 percent of wild animal species have been destroyed by humans, even though we make up only a tiny part of the weight of life, comprising one-one-hundredth of the total biomass. We have become the reckless tyrants of our planet. Many science fiction books and movies now simply assume that we are in the end phase of wrecking the environment. As J. Robert Oppenheimer said at the Trinity explosion of the atomic bomb, quoting Krishna from the Bhagavad Gita, "I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds." Now the fear of nuclear annihilation is being crowded out by other concerns—spreading regional wars, [End Page 6] uncontrolled technology, and especially the devastation of the atmosphere and biosphere. Serious human thought today is ruled by empirical science and an awareness of our striking fallibility. It is oddly like the attitudes of Western European thinkers in the 1700s, when empiricism and Augustinian Christianity emphasized not just the limits of human reason and behavior but also our self-destructiveness. We have dealt with overwhelming problems in the past through communication, science, democracy, and education. These methods can be turned on their heads and misused, yet in the broad scheme they have so far led to progress. If we are to avoid what Oppenheimer feared, we had better get to work. Much of this issue explores human-animal relations. Two essays focus on the lives of modern-day herds and herders: Kathryn Wilder's "After Birth," a runner-up in our 33rd annual Jeffrey E. Smith Editors' Prize competition, is about cattle ranching in southwestern Colorado during a difficult winter, and Matthew Denton-Edmundson, the winner in nonfiction, reflects on his time as a goatherd in "How to Love Animals." Wilder's essay is a stunning high-country epic that follows the travails of a herd during calving season: cows and cowherds struggle together through frostbite, birth complications, and coyote attacks. Though more focused on the technical business of managing a large herd, Wilder's essay, like Denton-Edmundson's, shows obvious compassion toward animals. As the title suggests, "How to Love Animals" is an ardent guide to achieving "more complex, entangled relationship[s] with animals . . . , in which we allow them to alter us almost as much as we alter them," to our mutual benefit. He uses his experiences as the caretaker for a small herd of goats to describe shared happiness as a point of connection between people and animals, whose lives can enhance our own when we work to understand them better. The other two essays in this issue are also concerned with happiness and the effort to find it during great change. In "My Cape Disappointment," Debra Dean reflects on the depression she felt after returning, as an adult, to live with her family in the Pacific Northwest, where Lewis and Clark also struggled to keep up their morale in 1805. Framing her essay as an exploration narrative, Dean shows a resilience that reminds us, like T. S. Eliot, to "fare forward" if we can't always "fare well." Similarly, Maureen Stanton's "The Birds" is an attempt to avoid what she calls "the Big Sad" during the...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Speer Morgan (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: