Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Bede, Augustine, and Paul Daniel J. Heisey O.S.B. (bio) INTRODUCTION In the early eighth century, at a monastery in the kingdom of Northumbria, in the northeast of what is now England, Bede (c. 673–735) pored over Eugippius's Excerpta ex Operibus Sancti Augustini. Those excerpts formed a compendium of the works of Augustine of Hippo and, with reference to Augustine's complete writings, Bede compiled his own anthology of Augustine's comments on the epistles then attributed to Paul the Apostle.1 That collection remains a curiosity among Bede's works, since it lacks a preface to explain why Bede wrote it. Nevertheless, it can shed light on Bede's use of Augustine, as well as Bede's understanding of Paul. In particular, it shows how Bede interpreted 1 Timothy 3:1, on desiring the office of bishop. The way that Bede drew upon Augustine's writings, often by way of Eugippius, provides a perspective on how monks in the Anglo-Saxon era viewed a pastoral office. Although modern biblical scholars doubt the Pauline authorship of the two letters to Timothy, known as Pastoral Epistles, patristic and medieval exegetes believed otherwise.2 For those earlier scholars, traditional attribution to Paul sufficed. Moreover, as Pope Benedict XVI observed, even if the Pastoral Epistles came from the pen of someone writing in a "Pauline school," they "reflect his legacy for a new generation, perhaps including some words or brief passages written by the Apostle himself."3 [End Page 58] In any case, Bede's use of Augustine on Paul can be instructive for a student of history. For even if, as David Hurst has suggested, Bede's culling from Augustine was a florilegium meant for his own use, Bede's work as a monk and priest was to teach and preach.4 Thus, even private jottings in a notebook would eventually inform what he presented to others. EUGIPPIUS Before proceeding, however, a word is in order about Eugippius. He lived from around 455 to 533, thus a century after Augustine, and he served as abbot of a monastery at Castellum Lucullanum, near Naples. Eugippius, then, was an older contemporary of Benedict of Nursia (c. 480–547) and neighbor to Benedict's monastery at Monte Cassino. In the sixth century, Cassiodorus used Eugippius's writings, as did Isidore of Seville in the seventh century.5 Sometime in the late seventh century, a copy of Eugippius's gleanings from Augustine made its way to Bede's monastic library.6 When writing about Anglo-Saxon libraries, Michael Lapidge pointed out that if, instead of having a shelf full of Augustine's writings, Bede's library contained only Eugippius's book, the number of Augustine's works available to Bede "would be reduced drastically from forty-eight to eighteen."7 However many volumes by Augustine [End Page 59] Bede's library contained, Bede's variation upon the Eugippean theme remains an impressive achievement, running in its English translation to more than three hundred pages.8 While it attests to Bede's mastery of the collected works of Augustine, it also poses a challenge for modern study and distillation. For that reason, it is simpler to consider one part of Bede's transcription from Augustine, such as a single verse from one of the Pastoral Epistles. Whatever indication these extracts give of the number of volumes by Augustine in Bede's monastic library at Wearmouth-Jarrow, Bede's excerpts from Augustine on Paul reveal, amongst other things, glimpses into early medieval monastic expectations for bishops. Also, Bede's compilation shows something of what monks meant by the apostolic life. AUGUSTINE ON BISHOPS Since in modern editions Augustine's collected works fill several shelves, here it is appropriate to limit Augustine's comments on 1 Timothy 3:1 to only one of his writings. In Chapter 19 of Book 19 of his City of God, Augustine wrote about the role of bishops, and in order to support his case, Augustine cited what for him was a text by Paul, 1 Timothy 3:1. There Paul said, "The saying is sure: If any one aspires to the office of a bishop, he desires a noble task...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Daniel J. Heisey (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: