Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviewed by: The Inner Life of Catholic Reform: From the Council of Trent to the Enlightenment by Ulrich L. Lehner Noah R. Karger The Inner Life of Catholic Reform: From the Council of Trent to the Enlightenment by Ulrich L. Lehner ( Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2022), 312 pp. In The Inner Life of Catholic Reform, Ulrich Lehner explores an overlooked aspect of Catholic Reform, one he considers central. This 250-year period—its beginning marked by the Council of Trent (1545–1563)—is normally understood through institutional and political lenses. Lehner, however, attends to its "inner life," or the "practices and beliefs" of the time "that would spiritually transform the individual" (ix). Shifting focus from exterior to interior, from macro to micro, Lehner's work provides fresh insight into the nuances of Catholic Reform. He labors to prove its centrality not simply to the socio-political systems that individuals operated inside of—as has long been established—but to the spiritual experiences, beliefs, and practices they operated through and from. Lehner employs "Catholic Reform" in lieu of "Counter-Reformation" because his treatment of the movement is not in reference to the Protestant Reformation. Rather, he deals with Catholicism's reform on its own terms. However, as he notes in the preface, the work is not meant to exhaustively chronicle Catholic Reform's many events, as he focuses specifically on the beliefs and practices of spiritual transformation. Lehner says that, in writing [End Page 694] the book, he "took only a small bag of pearls from the treasury and left the rest untouched" (xi). The work is thus intended to supplement rather than replace other histories of Catholic Reform. Though Catholic Reform is commonly associated with Trent, Lehner outlines in the first chapter how this is somewhat misleading. Trent, he argues, "never articulated a passionate vision of reform," as it "served more like a symbol than an actual force of reform" (3, 157). He therefore deems "Tridentism" an unsuitable designation for what he is concerned with in this book. Lehner argues that, instead, this "reform" ought to be understood via two senses associated with the word: (1) reformatio in pristinum (reformation into the former) and (2) reformatio ad melius (reformation for the better). The first is oriented to a normative past, the second to a normative future. By taking these together—reform as recovery and innovation—Lehner underscores a common historiographical error in the treatment of Catholic Reform. In understanding it primarily in reference to the Protestant Reformation, historians have too often interpreted the project as a form of reactionary conservatism. While Catholic reformers sought to preserve theological orthodoxy, they nevertheless encouraged new developments in discipline and catechesis. The "adaptation of old ideas to new circumstances" was in fact prominent during Catholic Reform (6). In adapting old ideas, reformers were chiefly concerned with the cura animarum (cure of souls), "in overcoming the bifurcation between theological erudition and lived faith" (9). Therefore, Lehner's study is primarily one of devotional theology, drawing on "the catechism, the homily, the prayer book, and the hymn" (9). In doing so, he depicts the Catholic reformer as one who sought, above all else, to conform their will to God's, a self-transforming pursuit of holiness. This pursuit was by no means stoical, but emerged in and through converting passions into affects, ordering them unto the love of God. Pedagogically, a "dialectical pattern of fear and mercy" was thought to be instructive in this work of converting passion to affect, as Lehner demonstrates throughout (94). The individual reformer's affective inner work was conceived as deeply connected to their communal relations, specifically families. According to Lehner, post-Trent theology "recognized [the family] as the center of all church reform" (11). Thus, in discussing the inner life of Catholic reformers, Lehner never locates them in isolation from their societal structures. Rather, he rightfully discovers the telos of these structures in reference to the spiritual perfection after which they sought. Because Lehner does not spend precious word count on the major events and persons which are common in sequential overviews, he is able instead [End Page 695] to devote his attention to "the ordinary faithful" (1). Herein lies...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Noah R. Karger (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: