Effects from particle motion and substrate-borne vibration on fishes and invertebrates: Recommendations on research questions and methodologies

There have been substantially increased interest in effects of particle motion and substrate-borne vibration on fishes and aquatic invertebrates over the past decade. This is because these signals, unlike sound pressure, are the basis of hearing in most fishes and in all aquatic invertebrates. However, studies to address these issues continue to face challenges due to the diversity of species, the broad range of hearing mechanism, and the complexity of the physical acoustic environment in conducting studies. Additionally, we do not yet have a good understanding of, and mechanisms for, source generation, calibration, and measurements to be able to examine effects properly. Related to this is the critical issue is how research questions are applicable to regulatory agencies. In October 2023, the US Bureau of Ocean Energy Management held a workshop to address different research methodologies and their pros and cons as the basis for study of the behavioral and physiological responses to particle motion and substrate-borne vibration. Subsequently, a review was conducted linking research priorities previously identified concerning anthropogenic noise effects on animals with appropriate research methodologies. The review also provides recommendations on experimental settings that are most appropriate to address specific research questions for regulatory concerns.