Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Feeling Implicated Shir Alon (bio) THE IMPLICATED SUBJECT: BEYOND VICTIMS AND PERPETRATORS BY MICHAEL ROTHBERG Stanford University Press, 2019 The short Israeli documentary Mirror Image (2013) is one of those films about the making of the film itself: for most of its eleven minutes, the director Danielle Schwartz sits with her grandparents at their sunny kitchen table as they negotiate the precise wording of a text that should serve as the film's basis: the story of the large crystal mirror displayed at the entrance of the grandparents' home. Surrounded by family photographs, this mirror reflects the images of anyone coming in or out. The mirror, everyone agrees, is originally from the Palestinian village Zarnuqa and came into the family's possession in the aftermath of the destruction of the village and the expulsion of its citizens in the Nakba of 1948. "Why can't we say that the mirror was— apparently, most likely— looted?" Schwartz asks her grandparents. They, in turn, argue for a "softer," more ambivalent term: the mirror was "taken." But it is uncertain who took it and when; in any case, her grandparents claim they had nothing to do with it. Negotiations continue until they reach an agreed-upon version. What makes this film so arresting? First, the tone. It's a warm but clearly tense intergenerational dialogue. Schwartz is not accusatory: her grandparents are evidently not guilty of looting the mirror— they got it as a gift from Schwartz's great-grandfather when they moved into their first home— nor does she indict them for enjoying the spoils of war. She only attempts to acknowledge, in a cinematic document, their material implication in a violent history. The grandparents, however, adamantly refuse to look into the mirror, as Schwartz asks them [End Page 165] to, and see themselves as part of a story of violence and dispossession. "It happened to the mirror," the grandmother says, "not to us." What is at stake in this refused recognition? What would have happened if the grandparents had agreed with their granddaughter, seeing the mirror as the trace of a distant yet still very active violence? Would it change the way they look at it, or the way they inhabit their home? The unspoken logic underlying their negotiations with Schwartz is that even though they are not guilty of taking the mirror, acknowledging that they do have "something to do with it," and that they are the beneficiaries of a violence that continues to play out in Israel's ethnonationalist colonial order, would deem them, in a very tangible yet unnamed sense, responsible. The contours and effects of such responsibility are the subject matter of Michael Rothberg's The Implicated Subject: Beyond Victims and Perpetrators. Implicated subjects, Rothberg states in the book's opening, "occupy positions aligned with power and privilege without being themselves direct agents of harm; they contribute to, inhabit, inherit, or benefit from regimes of domination but do not originate or control such regimes" (1). Implication is a relational position within hierarchies and histories of violence and inequality, the inevitable fact of our often passive enfoldment within orders of harm. The Implicated Subject offers a conceptual definition and an analysis of this enfoldment's ethical implications. As a term, implication is conveniently middle-of-the-road, less damning than the legalistic "complicity" and less personal than the fashionable "privilege." Rothberg identifies it with a critical yet under-theorized position within our ethical vocabulary, a term that allows us to "enlarge our understanding of the actors involved in injustices" beyond a narrow legalistic definition of perpetrators, victims, and bystanders (202). Introducing the sprawling mesh of implication modifies all three of these categories: most immediately, it does away with the figure of the neutral bystander in favor of the subject always already embroiled in social hierarchies and injustices. Secondly, the concept of implication aims to dismantle the absolutist categories of victims and perpetrators, as it highlights the multiple and multidirectional involvements of any individual in oppressive or injurious structures. Rothberg brings the insights of Black feminist theorists of intersectionality to bear on distant historical sites and case studies: the [End Page 166] legacies of plantation colonies, South African...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Shir Alon (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: