Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Random Acts of Medicine: The Hidden Forces That Sway Doctors, Impact Patients, and Shape Our Health by Anupam B. Jena, M.D., Ph.D., and Christopher Worsham, M.D., M.P.H., is fascinating, entertaining, and provocative. These talented writers explore the role of randomness in patients' and physicians' lives and illustrate how natural experiments can transform this randomness into important insights. They are well equipped to do so. Dr. Anupam Bapu Jena studied economics and biology at Massachusetts Institute of Technology (Cambridge, Massachusetts) and completed his medical degree and Ph.D. in economics at the University of Chicago (Chicago, Illinois). He practices medicine at Massachusetts General Hospital (Boston, Massachusetts), where he completed his residency in internal medicine, and is a professor of healthcare policy and medicine at Harvard Medical School (Boston, Massachusetts). Dr. Jena is also a faculty research associate at the National Bureau of Economic Research (Cambridge, Massachusetts) and hosts the "Freakonomics MD" podcast, which delves into the "hidden side of health care." Dr. Christopher Worsham is a pulmonary and critical care physician at Massachusetts General Hospital and is a healthcare policy researcher at Harvard Medical School. He received a B.S. in statistics from the University of Michigan (Ann Arbor, Michigan). A graduate of Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth (Hanover, New Hampshire), Dr. Worsham trained in internal medicine at Boston Medical Center and completed his subspecialty training and public health education at Harvard University.Chance happenings breeze into our lives unexpectedly and can dramatically change the course of our existence. Although we cannot eradicate randomness from our lives, we can learn from it. Although randomized controlled trials have long been venerated as medicine's most powerful and preferred tool for investigating cause and effect, they have notable limitations. Randomized controlled trials can be logistically challenging, expensive to execute, consume unreasonable amounts of time, and even be categorically unethical. In contrast, a natural experiment is an observational study in which individuals are exposed to experimental and control conditions that are determined by nature or by other factors outside the control of the investigators. The process governing the exposures arguably resembles random assignment. Researchers in some fields, especially economics, have come to rely on natural experiments rather than randomized controlled trials, just as the "father of epidemiology," Dr. John Snow, used a natural experiment to discover, in 1854, that drinking contaminated water from London's Broad Street pump caused and disseminated cholera. (Unfortunately, the authors do not mention that Dr. Snow [1813 to 1858] was also a pioneering anesthesiologist whose intellectual curiosity and keen powers of observation enabled him to study 16 different gases, including ether and chloroform, and establish the inverse relationship between blood solubility and partial pressure. His interest in anesthesia-related mortality was another major contribution to the nascent medical specialty.) Indeed, natural experiments have been demonstrated to be such a powerful tool that three pioneers of their modern use—David Card, Joshua Angrist, and Guido Imbens—received the Nobel Prize in economics in 2021.Natural experiments can expose the hidden forces in health care, such as chance and unconscious clinician bias, that can affect outcome. These chance events create natural experiments that can assist us in navigating the gray areas of modern medicine. One chapter probes the question, "What happens when all the cardiologists leave town?" Another enticing chapter asks, "What do cardiac surgeons and used-car salesmen have in common?" (Spoiler alert: so-called left-digit bias may contribute to decision-making disparities and outcome differences.) Importantly, the authors also tackle the thorny issue of politics at the bedside. Although much of the book highlights how physicians' humanity renders them flawed in the sense that they are vulnerable to errors and (usually) unconscious bias, the authors acknowledge that humanity is essential to the medical profession. Humanity enables physicians to connect with patients, to see the patient as a whole person with values, hopes, and fears rather than merely the sum of cells, tissues, and organs. The book's penultimate chapter examines "What makes a good doctor?" Answers to this query are illuminating as one learns the roles that clinician age and sex, specialty, perceived status, and geographical location (e.g., domestic vs. international) of the physician's medical school, and other factors may (or may not) play. Any attempt to encapsulate these sections in more detail would not do justice to the rich flavor of the book; readers are exhorted to scrutinize the volume in its entirety.As a testament to the authors' engaging writing skills, it took me more than a few chapters to recall how much I preferred my many college mathematics courses to my one (required) economics course. I viewed mathematics as a discipline that was elegant, definitive, precise, and logical. The same could not be said about economics, which struck me as tentative, convoluted, and subjective. (Tired of hearing economists say, "On one hand…but then again on the other…," it is no wonder that President Harry Truman yearned for a "one-handed" economist!) Yet, I must admit that the inclusion of a physician-economist as a coauthor adds a valuable dimension and interesting perspective to this book.Random Acts of Medicine is a worthy supplement to the excellent books authored by Drs. Danielle Ofri and Jerome Groopman. Specifically, I am referring to Dr. Ofri's What Doctors Feel: How Emotions Affect the Practice of Medicine1 and Dr. Groopman's How Doctors Think.2I highly recommend Random Acts of Medicine, which incorporates helpful notes, an extensive bibliography, and a detailed index, to all physicians regardless of specialty as well as to patients who are interested in assuming a more proactive approach to their health care. The book has the potential to enhance the physician-patient relationship through better understanding of one another's vulnerabilities. Indeed, part of the beauty of this book is that the authors encourage physicians to recognize the many components of their reality as healers, although the ultimate experiential reality of life as a physician may remain forever elusive. We are, after all, imperfect and finite beings whose perspective is limited despite our best efforts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kathryn E. McGoldrick (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: