Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This analysis compares the ASME local failure criterion and the Bao-Wierzbicki model, suggesting the latter may offer better predictions in low triaxiality states.
The ASME Local Failure Criterion, discussed in Section VIII, Division 2 of the ASME Boiler & Pressure Vessel Code, is widely used in pressure vessels and piping design as a method of predicting the initiation of local fissuring under a variety of different stress states. This relation maps the expected failure strain to the degree of triaxiality in a localized region, taking the form of a monotonically decaying exponential curve that passes through the point represented by the strain to failure at a uniaxial tension triaxiality state of +1/3. In this work, we present an investigation of an alternative failure locus (Bao-Wierzbicki) in low-triaxiality states where the ASME fracture locus struggles to predict shear failures. Being a piecewise-continuous ductility model with a pronounced local minimum at the zero-triaxiality position (i.e., pure shear), the Bao-Wierzbicki (B-W) model provides a more tunable representation of mixed-mode failure than the ASME default equation, particularly in low triaxiality where the ASME model predicts unrealistically high ductility. Through a series of experimental and numerical analyses, we demonstrate the efficacy of the B-W model in predicting the thread-stripping failure mode in a study of mechanically-simulated corrosion of ASTM A563 nuts interacting with intact ASTM A325 bolts. In comparison to common pressure vessel bolting, A325 bolts have a yield-to-ultimate strength ratio (R) of 0.77, whereas more commonly used A193 Grade B7 bolts have R ratios closer to 0.84. Our findings suggest that the B-W model may be preferred over the current ASME model for some applications in Pressure Vessel design and analysis activities, such as assessment of thread stripping.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Attaran et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: