The rising urbanization and climate change have increased pluvial flood risks, especially in highly urbanized areas. This study focuses on the Lake Ganzirri area in Messina, Italy, where street-level floods have raised concerns for infrastructure resilience and public safety. This study aims to explore how to effectively represent key urban features, emphasizing buildings and low-impact development/sustainable urban drainage systems (LID/SUDS). For the buildings, a combination of referred approaches to represent buildings is compared against the widely used method to represent buildings as voids in a 2D mesh, ignoring them in the water balance calculations. For the LID/SUDS control elements, a 2D representation is presented and compared against the widely used 1D approach to model such elements. The study uses three well-known software packages—EPA-SWMM 5.2, HEC-RAS 6.2, and InfoWorks ICM 2021.9—applied to the Lake Ganzirri area, to explore the representation of buildings using the building void method (available in InfoWorks ICM 2021.9) against the proposed method (in HEC-RAS 6.2) to replicate runoff flow over a 2D model of a highly urbanized area. From scenario S0, three more scenarios were derived: S1 (S0 with pluvial drainage network), S2 (S1 with LID/SUDS control elements), and S3 (S0 with 2D representation of LID/SUDS), which were then compared against using four comparison schemes. Results show that the proposed method for representing buildings computed the propagation of the runoff comparable to when the building void method is used, with some shortcomings regarding mesh adjustments and computational times. Regarding the 2D representation of LID/SUDS, the effects were unperceivable on water depth maps (reduction in water depths of 1.5 mm on average for all the rainfall events). Still, they were reflected in the increase of 62% of the infiltration volume on average of all the rainfall scenarios and a decrease of 9.1% of water flowing outside the 2D area, therefore replicating the effect of capturing water.
Chano et al. (Wed,) studied this question.