Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviewed by: Celebrating Charlotte Brontë Transforming Life into Literature in Jane Eyre by Christine Alexander and Sara L. Pearson Amber Pouliot (bio) Christine Alexander and Sara L. Pearson, Celebrating Charlotte Brontë: Transforming Life into Literature in Jane Eyre (The Brontë Society, 2016) 204 pages, ISBN 978-0-9505829-0-0 In her article "Haworth, November 1904," Virginia Woolf was famously apprehensive about how the preservation and display of Charlotte Brontë's material remains might affect her posthumous reputation. Woolf vacillates between fascination and embarrassment, as if her gaze somehow violates the privacy of the deceased and contributes to the erasure of Charlotte's identity as a writer. "An effort," she explains, ought to be made to keep things out of these mausoleums, but the choice often lies between them and destruction, so that we must be grateful for the care which has preserved much that is, under any circumstances, of deep interest. … But the most touching case—so touching that one hardly feels reverent in one's gaze—is that which contains the little personal relics of the dead woman. The natural fate of such things is to die before the body that wore them, and because these, trifling and transient though they are, have survived, Charlotte Brontë the woman comes to life, and one forgets the chiefly memorable fact that she was a great writer. Her shoes and her thin muslin dress have outlived her. (126)1 Charlotte's material remains are interesting, touching and, crucially, capable of illuminating her day-to-day domestic experience—the immediate context in which she composed all of her novels and poetry. If viewed objectively, they could help us understand her personal experience and creative process. And yet Woolf understood that the shoes and dresses and other personal property would necessarily be interpreted through the lens of Elizabeth Gaskell's hagiographical biography, The Life of Charlotte Brontë (1857), and the many subsequent works on the Brontës that were influenced by it. They would be transmuted into relics that confirmed popular perceptions of Brontë's life as miserable and deprived. They had the power to shift discussions away from her artistry and onto her perceived domestic misery. And for that reason, they were dangerous. Today, one hundred years after the publication of Woolf's essay, two hundred years after the birth of Charlotte Brontë, and sixty years after the rise of formalism and New Criticism, the study of Victorian literature has taken a decisively material turn, betraying a fascination with things, places, and the acts of tourism undertaken to experience them, all of which were once rather derisively deemed the paratextual. Inspired, perhaps, by works like Elaine Freedgood's The Ideas in Things (2006), with its discussion of ebony furniture in Jane Eyre (1847), and Lucasta Miller's indispensable The Brontë Myth (2001), there have been a spate of publications examining the Brontës' lives, literature, and legacies in relation to their material world and the ways in which it has been collected, recorded, and preserved. These include Nicola Watson's The Literary Tourist (2006) and Literary Tourism and [End Page 322] Nineteenth-Century Culture (2009), Deborah Lutz's The Brontë Cabinet (2015), and Alison Booth's Homes and Haunts (2016). Christine Alexander and Sara L. Pearson's remarkable Celebrating Charlotte Brontë: Transforming Life into Literature in Jane Eyre (2016) is a meticulously researched and immensely rich addition to this growing body of work on the Brontës and the intersection of the material and literary. Commissioned by the Brontë Parsonage Museum as part of their program of commemorations for Charlotte's 2016 bicentenary, the book sets out to illuminate the ways in which Brontë imaginatively transformed her every day, material surroundings into the material of her best-loved work of fiction, Jane Eyre. Divided into chapters that correspond with those in the first edition of Jane Eyre, this large and handsome volume is illustrated with nearly three hundred photographs of the "things" that Brontë's characters encounter. There are photographs of portraits and landscapes, maps, children's toys, crockery, hair jewelry, handicraft, clothing, and haberdashery, as well as photos of Charlotte's manuscript handwriting and the visual art she produced throughout her...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Amber Pouliot (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: