Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Observational analysis revealed non-compliance during tasks in a petrochemical facility, indicating procedural variation is an adaptive response.
Hollnagel’s work on Safety-I and Safety-II, Work-as-Imagined (WAI) and Work-as-Done (WAD), and the Efficiency–Thoroughness Trade-Off (ETTO) has reshaped how safety researchers and practitioners understand human performance in complex systems. Building on this legacy, the present study investigates how workers in a petrochemical facility navigate written procedures during everyday operations. Using head-mounted video recordings, we analyzed 1,422 procedural steps across 40 operations, comparing paper-based and digital procedures. A Skip-Order-Action (SOA) Framework is introduced to investigate deviations between WAI and WAD, moving beyond binary notions of compliance and non-compliance. Results showed that approximately one-third of steps deviated from prescribed methods, yet all tasks were completed successfully, underscoring the adaptive role of procedural variation. Analyses further revealed that the type of procedural variation (Skip, Order, Action) changed significantly depending on the operational phase. Crucially, variability was driven primarily by contextual factors, such as operational phase and procedural medium, rather than individual worker differences, emphasizing the systemic nature of adaptation. These findings provide empirical support for Hollnagel’s call to understand why work succeeds and demonstrate how procedural variability can be conceptualized as functional adaptation rather than error. By operationalizing Safety-II concepts through the SOA Framework, this study extends Hollnagel’s vision of safety as an emergent property of everyday work.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ashraf et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: