Influence of Alkyne Precursor Structure on Carbon Nanotube Chiral Distribution: Data-Dense Analysis Across Multiple Catalyst Types

Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) are a desirable material in the field of optoelectronics and semiconductors due to electronic properties (e.g., bandgap) that are dependent upon their chirality, defined by their diameter and lattice angle. Unfortunately, industrial-scale syntheses have yet to realize growth of a single desired chirality and instead rely on postsynthetic separation techniques to refine a chiral mixture, which increases process complexity and cost. Here, we studied the influence of precursor structure on chiral distribution, using a series of terminal alkyne precursors (acetylene, methylacetylene, vinylacetylene, 1-butyne, two enantiomers of 3-butyn-2-ol and a racemic mixture thereof) to grow CNTs across five transition-metal catalysts (Fe, FeMo, and three proportions of CoMo). Multiwavelength Raman spectroscopy on 5,145 spots (5 catalysts, 7 precursors, 3 lasers, and 49 distinct substrate locations on each) determined that acetylene grew the smallest diameter CNTs, while vinylacetylene produced fewer subnanometer CNTs. Though precursor structure did not dictate a uniform chiral shift, it was shown to broaden or narrow chiral distribution, while catalyst structure played a dominant role. This is consistent with metal-precursor binding occurring through unsaturated bonds in the hydrocarbons via the alkyne polymerization mechanism.