Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Qualitative study reveals decision-making complexities influenced by culture and religion among families of frail elderly ICU patients.
Background Family members of frail elderly intensive care unit (ICU) patients shoulder complex surrogate decisions under prognostic uncertainty, cultural expectations and moral strain—particularly in Middle Eastern settings where collective responsibility and religion shape choices. Aim To explore how families experience and navigate ICU decision‐making for frail elderly relatives and to identify culturally distinctive mechanisms. Study Design Qualitative descriptive study using reflexive thematic analysis. Results Fifteen Arabic‐language, in‐depth interviews (45–90 min) with family decision‐makers in Saudi Arabia were audio‐recorded, transcribed, translated and analysed following Braun and Clarke‘s six phases. Rigour was supported by memoing, interpretive meetings and an audit trail. Sample adequacy was justified via information power (sufficiency at n = 13 with two confirming interviews). Three themes emerged: (1) Burden of Decision —emotional paralysis, moral ambivalence about withholding/withdrawing life‐sustaining treatment and episodic isolation within surrogate roles; (2) Consultative Family Deliberation ( shūrā )—distributed roles, intergenerational negotiation and prioritisation of family harmony; and (3) Faith‐Driven Acceptance —tawakkul (trust in divine will), prayer/ritual as anchors and reframing death as a spiritual transition rather than treatment failure. Frailty (Clinical Frailty Scale ≥ 5) heightened uncertainty and, for some, oriented preferences towards comfort‐focused care. Conclusions Family decision‐making for frail elderly ICU patients is culturally embedded, relational and spiritually mediated. Relevance to Clinical Practice Nurse‐led, culturally responsive supports—structured inclusive family meetings, Arabic values‐clarification aids and facilitation of spiritual needs—may reduce decisional burden, enhance trust and align care with family values.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ali et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: