A rifted margin can be regarded, in the first place, as a crustal thinning taper framed by “box-shaped” continental and oceanic crusts whose top basement and Moho are parallel. Attempts to understand the relationship between lithosphere extension, crustal thinning and strain localization have been addressed in part by characterizing and modeling rift modes. However, a weakness of models stems from their using generalized physical parameters and initial conditions, while each system is unique in terms of its geological complexity. In this study, we develop a new approach to investigate the relation between crustal shape, the nature of the top basement and the accommodation space to reveal the link between extension, strain localization and crustal thinning in the northern South China Sea (N-SCS). Our results show the following: (1) box-shaped crusts may indicate no or minor extension, or extension compensated by crustal flow and/or magmatic additions; (2) crustal thinning and strain localization occurred through extensional detachment faults coevally during the rifting of the N-SCS; (3) strain localization was triggered or enhanced by magmatic weakening, and the weak crustal rheology at the onset of the rifting favored the formation of detachment faults; and (4) the inherited composition of the crust (magmatic rocks in the arc and meta-sediments in the forearc) controls the distribution of crustal thinning. We propose that the different initial conditions, changes in extension rates and the presence/absence of subduction dynamics account for the different rift evolutions observed in the SCS and Atlantic-type rift systems.
Zhang et al. (Sat,) studied this question.