Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Analysis examines how testing protocols influence male-female differences in exercise intensity outcomes.
Rationale: Exercise intensity is often prescribed as a percentage of a “maximum” reference point. Both the choice of reference and the protocol to obtain it may bias apparent female–male differences in relative intensity. Objective: To examine whether female–male differences in relative intensity expressed relative to a maximum reference (⩒O₂max or PPO) differ depending on the protocol used to determine it (ramp vs. step). Methods: Fifty trained cyclists (30 males, 20 females, 31±8 years old, ⩒O₂max 3866±840ml/min) completed a ramp‐incremental and a 3-min step test on a cycle ergometer. Thresholds were determined from fixed and individualized blood lactate concentrations and from ventilation. Relative intensity was expressed in relation to PPO and ⩒O₂max derived from each protocol. Linear mixed-effects models with participant as random intercept tested the fixed effects of Sex, Protocol, and their interaction. Agreement between ramp- and step-derived ⩒O₂max values was evaluated using Bland–Altman analysis. For ⩒O₂-based relative intensity, only protocol effects were small but significant (all p<0.01). For Power, Sex had a significant influence in the models with males displaying higher relative intensities in all lactate-based thresholds (all p≤0.02). Sex × Protocol interactions emerged for BLa 2 and BLa min+0.5 (both p<0.05), indicating that using step or ramp protocols as reference can alter the magnitude or direction of female–male differences. Conclusions: Apparent sex differences in relative intensity depend on how “maximum” is defined and obtained. The same relative intensity does not ensure equivalent physiological strain across sexes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Meixner et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: