Compact CNNs offer the best efficiency-performance trade-offs in data-limited settings, while Transformers and hybrid models improve long-range temporal representation at a higher computational cost.
The field of EEG-based classification is shifting toward lightweight hybrid deep learning designs that balance local feature extraction with global temporal modeling.
Feature extraction (FE) is an important step in electroencephalogram (EEG)-based classification for brain–computer interface (BCI) systems and neurocognitive monitoring. However, the dynamic and low-signal-to-noise nature of EEG data makes achieving robust FE challenging. Recent deep learning (DL) advances have offered alternatives to traditional manual feature engineering by enabling end-to-end learning from raw signals. In this paper, we present a comparative review of 88 DL models published over the last decade, focusing on EEG FE. We examine convolutional neural networks (CNNs), Transformer-based mechanisms, recurrent architectures including recurrent neural networks (RNNs) and long short-term memory (LSTM), and hybrid models. Our analysis focuses on architectural adaptations, computational efficiency, and classification performance across EEG tasks. Our findings reveal that efficient EEG FE depends more on architectural design than model depth. Compact CNNs offer the best efficiency–performance trade-offs in data-limited settings, while Transformers and hybrid models improve long-range temporal representation at a higher computational cost. Thus, the field is shifting toward lightweight hybrid designs that balance local FE with global temporal modeling. This review aims to guide BCI developers and future neurotechnology research toward efficient, scalable, and interpretable EEG-based classification frameworks.
Hallal et al. (Sun,) conducted a review in EEG-based classification for brain-computer interface systems and neurocognitive monitoring. Deep learning models (CNNs, Transformers, RNNs, hybrid models) vs. Traditional manual feature engineering was evaluated on Architectural adaptations, computational efficiency, and classification performance across EEG tasks. Compact CNNs offer the best efficiency-performance trade-offs in data-limited settings, while Transformers and hybrid models improve long-range temporal representation at a higher computational cost.