The rapid expansion of non-dispatchable renewable energy sources (VRE) and energy storage technologies raises fundamental questions regarding the structural limits of their integration into power systems. This study aims to determine, from a structural reliability perspective, the adequate penetration limits of VRE in a synthetic power system and to assess how firm generation share, storage capacity, and wind–solar technology mix influence system reliability. A synthetic annual load profile reflecting current European conditions was developed from real-life data, along with a set of indicators enabling the consistent characterization and comparison of demand profiles. A deterministic system model was then applied to evaluate power and energy balance under parametrized configurations of firm generation, variable renewable capacity, and storage. Reliability performance was assessed using proposed indices (RIs) covering, among others, capacity margin, loss of load duration, frequency, etc. The results demonstrate the existence of structural penetration limits of non-dispatchable renewables that cannot be eliminated solely by increasing storage capacity, but only shifted. The technological composition of VRE is shown to be as important as total penetration: higher wind shares improve seasonal alignment and reduce reliability risks, whereas PV-dominated configurations increase curtailment and storage dependence. Moderate overcapacity, combined with a balanced wind–solar mix, provides the most favorable structural reliability conditions. These findings underscore the importance of incorporating reliability-based structural constraints into long-term energy transition planning, beyond purely economic optimization criteria.
Uchman et al. (Sun,) studied this question.