ConspectusOne of the most central questions in chemistry is how a starting material can be converted as simply and efficiently as possible into a product. The answer may include photocatalysis, and if the reaction proceeds well, one might argue that understanding the underlying mechanism is not essential. Even if the reaction does not perform as anticipated, condition screening may still provide the operationally simplest and most effective path to the desired outcome, while mechanistic aspects can remain largely unexamined. Given the large parameter space typically associated with modern photocatalytic reactions, this approach is both plausible and justified, particularly when product synthesis is the primary goal.A complementary perspective on modern photocatalysis focuses on the conceptual advancement of photochemistry and a deeper understanding of its elementary steps and their interplay. This type of research begins with classical mechanistic elucidation to break down complex processes into individual elementary events. Once sufficient understanding has been achieved, it can lead to the mechanistic design of photoreactions. At that stage, the sequence of photophysical and chemical events triggered by light, and consequently the overall outcome of the reaction, can become rationally predictable, at least in principle.In this Account, we examine how the cross-fertilization between synthetically oriented photoredox catalysis, which is primarily concerned with the activation and functionalization of organic molecules, and mechanistically driven research from the physical-inorganic domain has advanced the field of photochemistry. This interaction has often been catalyzed by controversial discussions surrounding the mechanistic details of reactions that have attracted significant synthetic interest. As a result, this interplay has propelled significant advances across several critical areas of modern molecular photocatalysis, including the reactivity of excited-state organic radicals and solvated electrons, the mechanisms underlying multiphoton excitation processes such as photon upconversion, the puzzling light-independent energy-loss phenomenon known as "cage escape", and even the possibility of challenging Kasha's rule, a foundational principle in photophysics with profound implications for photochemistry.The knowledge accumulated through this work has brought the field closer to achieving mechanistically guided design in photocatalysis, extending far beyond the initial light-induced step. Central to this advancement are modern time-resolved spectroscopic methods, which have provided crucial insights into transient species and reaction dynamics. This conceptual strategy opens new opportunities and highlights challenges in redefining thermodynamic and kinetic limits. Ultimately, combining mechanistic insight with the practical expertise of synthetic chemists offers great potential for continued innovation in photoredox catalysis at the intersection of organic and physical-inorganic chemistry. With this Account, we aim to bridge the gap between those who prioritize the synthetic perspective and those who emphasize mechanistic and conceptual approaches, fostering greater integration between organic chemists and physical-inorganic chemists.
Hardegger et al. (Thu,) studied this question.