Unexpected Persistence of the Predatory Mite Amblyseius andersoni Under Insecticide Exposure in Italian Apple Orchards

Predatory mites are key natural enemies in perennial crops, and their conservation is fundamental to ensure biocontrol of several pests. Yet their susceptibility to insecticides may compromise their role in Integrated Pest Management (IPM). In the past, pyrethroids proved to be poorly selective insecticides towards predatory mites, but in various countries their use recently increased in fruit orchards to counteract invasive pests. In this study, we assessed the effects of pyrethroids on the predatory mite Amblyseius andersoni through field experiments in apple orchards and laboratory assays on different strains. Field trials showed that A. andersoni populations remained unaffected by pyrethroid applications. Laboratory assays revealed intraspecific variation in A. andersoni populations: one commercial strain was highly susceptible to deltamethrin, whereas other commercial or field-collected strains were not affected, with no apparent sub-lethal effect on fecundity. These results underscore the contrasting susceptibility among predatory mite strains. From an IPM perspective, the lack of susceptibility to pyrethroids in A. andersoni may sustain biological control where insecticide use is unavoidable. Our findings stress the importance of evaluation procedures in toxicological studies, in particular the need to compare different strains, and of further investigation on predatory mite resistance. The implications for conservation programs in perennial cropping systems are addressed hereafter.