This research paper provides a comprehensive conceptual critique of the current framework of Ukrainian national identity and statehood. Spanning over 5,800 words, the study employs a socio-philosophical and legal analysis to deconstruct the overlaps between ethnic belonging (nationality) and political-legal status (citizenship). Key highlights of the research: · Conceptual Differentiation: The author establishes a rigorous formal distinction between the "national idea" and the "idea of the nation," offering original definitions for both constructs. · Identity Dilemmas: The study investigates the problematic interchangeability of ethnic and legal descriptors in contemporary Ukrainian discourse and its impact on state-building. · Original Framework: The paper introduces the novel concept of "social racketeering" to describe specific structural and socio-political dynamics within modern society. · Legal Perspective: Utilizing UDC 341 and DDC 323.6 classifications, the work situates the Ukrainian experience within the broader context of international law and state succession. The findings suggest a critical need for the development of new, positive social symbols and a unified conceptual framework to support sustainable state-building processes. Keywords: International Law, State Succession, Ukrainian Identity, Nationhood, Citizenship, Social Philosophy, Social Racketeering.
Dennis Segal (Sat,) studied this question.