Why the study?
The study aimed to compare physiological thresholds obtained from muscle near-infrared spectroscopy, heart rate variability, and heart rate with ventilatory parameters during a maximal incremental cycling test.
Do muscle NIRS and HRV-derived thresholds agree with ventilatory thresholds during an incremental cycling test in trained male cyclists?
Do muscle NIRS and HRV-derived thresholds agree with ventilatory thresholds during an incremental cycling test in trained male cyclists?
While mean values of NIRS and HRV-derived thresholds do not differ significantly from ventilatory thresholds, substantial inter-individual variability suggests they should complement rather than replace ventilatory thresholds for exercise prescription.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
NIRS/HRV thresholds should complement rather than replace ventilatory ones for exercise prescription; leaves open interchangeable use pending individualized validation.
This study aimed to compare different thresholds obtained from the muscle near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS), heart rate variability (HRV), HR and ventilatory parameters during a maximal incremental cycling test. Twenty trained male cyclists performed an incremental step test with breath-by-breath gas analysis, muscle NIRS-derived signal, HRV and HR continuously recorded. The first and second ventilatory thresholds (VT₁ and VT₂, respectively) were identified and compared to the other methods. The DMAX method was used to determine the NIRS-derived thresholds by oxygenated hemoglobin (O₂HbT), deoxygenated hemoglobin (HHbT), tissue saturation index (TSIT); HRV-derived thresholds by standard deviation of the instantaneous (SD1T) and continuous long-term RR intervals (SD2T) and HR deflection point. No significant differences were found between VT₁ and O₂HbT (171 ± 25 vs 179 ± 46 W; SEE = 23.0 W), VT₁ and SD1T (171 ± 39 W; SEE = 26.2 W) and VT₁ and SD2T (185 ± 37 W; SEE = 21.7 W); as well as between VT₂ and TSIT (242 ± 28 vs 230 ± 61 W; SEE = 25.1 W), when expressed as power-output, respectively. The standard error of estimate for these comparisons is approximately equivalent to one incremental stage (25 W). However, agreement analysis showed substantial inter-individual error (LoA up to ±107 W). This wide variability limits their precision for individual prescription, suggesting these methods should complement rather than substitute ventilatory thresholds.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nascimento et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: