Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This investigation reveals innovative consonant alternations in Slovak and Ukrainian dialects, suggesting a novel model of linguistic change.
Two discontinuous areas of Slavic – viz. Slovak and Ukrainian dialects – display etymologically unexpected and synchronically isolated alternations in the root-final consonant preceding the comparative marker -š-: Slk dial. vys-ok- ‘tall’ → vyk-š- ‘taller’; Ukr dial. blyz’-k- ‘close’ → blyk-š- ‘closer’. We investigate such alternations in both languages, taking into account previously unconsidered dialectal and historical data, and propose a novel analysis. We explain the phenomenon as due to analogical change, specifically a type we call Variant-Based Analogy (VBA), which consists in the replication of overabundance. In the situation a : α : α′ :: b : β, where α and α′ are isofunctional free variants paradigmatically related to a, an innovative form β′ may arise, copying the formal relationship between α and α′ (irrespective of the structure of a and b). Thus we explain Slk dial. vyk-š-í as an innovative variant of inherited vy-š-í, copying overabundance in cases such as dra-š-í ∼ drak-š-í ‘dearer’ (where both variants are motivated by their corresponding positive drah-ý ‘dear’). The mechanism differs from classical four-part analogy in that there is no structural parallelism between the relations a : α/ α′ and b : β/ β′: rather, β′ emerges as a free variant of an existing form and the preexistence of overabundance in the model is required. Due to the blindness to the “bases” a and b, the explanatory potential of VBA resembles Product-Oriented Innovation (POI) postulated in earlier literature, but it is more principled and constrained.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Szeptyński et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: