A Comparison of Sedimentary Characteristics and Architecture Between Sand-Rich and Mud-Rich Deltas: Insights from Flume Experiments

Existing studies have extensively investigated sand-rich shallow-water deltas. However, the sedimentary characteristics and internal architecture of mud-rich deltas remain poorly understood. In this study, two comparative flume experiments were conducted with sand–mud ratio as the key variable. High-resolution topographic data were acquired using a laser scanner to extract geometric parameters of the architectural elements. Three-dimensional architectural models were established and validated against the Ganjiang Delta (sand-rich) and the Ouchi River Delta (mud-rich) in China. The results reveal contrasting depositional styles: sand-rich deltas develop dense, laterally migrating braided channels with broad fan-shaped morphologies, forming blanket-like geometries that consist of vertically stacked and laterally amalgamated channel complexes with good connectivity; mud-rich deltas are characterized by stable channels with limited bifurcation, forming elongated finger-like morphologies with isolated, ribbon-like channel–mouth bar complexes that exhibit strong lateral heterogeneity and poor connectivity. These contrasting behaviors are governed by sediment cohesion: non-cohesive sands promote channel migration and dispersion, whereas cohesive silt and mud stabilize channels and focus sediment transport along main conduits. The experimental models successfully reproduce natural delta end-members, confirming the universal control of the sand–mud ratio. The established quantitative relationships provide a predictive basis for subsurface reservoir characterization and the formulation of differentiated development strategies.