Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article reconciles general and physical chemistry views on hydrogen atom degeneracy, indicating differing quantum number implications.
At the level of a general chemistry course, electrons in atoms possess four quantum numbers n, l, ml, and ms. For the hydrogen atom,energy depends only upon the principle quantum number n. Restrictions upon quantum numbers leadto a 2n2-fold degeneracy formula for a particular n. However, in a physical chemistry class, a more realistic and complete picture of atomic quantum numbers, energies, and degeneracy emerges. Spectroscopic terms characterizing atomic angular momentum are introduced. It is recognized that due to spin-orbit interaction in the hydrogen atom, ml and ms are no longer valid quantum numbers, and the existence of three new quantum numbers, s, j and mj, is acknowledged. Precise spectroscopic data shows that a hydrogen atom’s energy is no longer a function of n alone when n > 1. Presented here is an argument based upon term symbols showing that while 2n2 is not the correct degeneracy formula for the hydrogen atom, it is infact the number of distinct hydrogenic states consistent with a given n. The purpose of this article is to reconcile the general chemistry approach to the problem of hydrogen atom degeneracy with the physical chemistry approach. I write this article from the perspective of an instructor of physical chemistry whose students are sometimes puzzled by the seeming inconsistency of their general chemistry and physical chemistry courses with regard to the question of hydrogen atom degeneracy.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
David Keeports (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: