Aim: This study aims to explore the psychological effects of YouTube makeup tutorial videos by analyzing user comments through the lens of body image and appearance ideals, with a particular focus on themes related to body dysmorphic disorder (BDD). Method: A mixed-methods research design was used. A total of 2,000 comments were collected from the 10 most-viewed English-language makeup videos. The data were analyzed through thematic content analysis and sentiment analysis. Six major themes were identified: beauty admiration, negative self-comparison, cosmetic/behavioral intent, emotional reactions, opinion on content, and other. Each comment was also categorized as positive, neutral, or negative in sentiment. Results: The most frequent themes were “beauty admiration” and “opinion on content.” Comments praising appearance and makeup skills had the highest positive sentiment scores. Co-occurrence of subcodes, such as praise and envy, revealed emotionally complex reactions among viewers, suggesting an interplay between admiration and self-critical comparisons. Conclusion: While beauty content can foster inspiration and engagement, it also has the potential to heighten body dissatisfaction, promote harmful comparisons, and reinforce appearance-based validation. These findings highlight the importance of socially responsible beauty content and the need for mental health–supportive strategies on digital platforms.
Tayşi et al. (Tue,) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: