This study aims to determine the current seismic resistance of two masonry minarets that were severely damaged during the 6 February 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquakes, while also evaluating whether a model-updating approach based on experimental dynamic characteristics can reliably capture the actual seismic behavior and collapse mechanism of such structures under real earthquake conditions. The dynamic characteristics of the minarets were identified using Operational Modal Analysis (OMA) based on previous in-situ vibration measurements. These characteristics were used to calibrate finite element models through a model-updating process employing Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) methods. The initial modal analyses revealed discrepancies of up to 13.7% in natural frequencies and 9.7% in mode shapes. After applying MCDM methods to a wide set of model variants, these differences were reduced to 2.0% and 9.2%, respectively, improving the agreement between numerical and experimental results. Once the most representative models were obtained, nonlinear seismic analyses were performed using actual ground motion records from the earthquake. The results included evaluations of peak displacements, base shear forces, and principal stresses. The concentration of principal stresses near the transition zone showed good qualitative agreement with the observed collapse locations, indicating a reasonable consistency between numerical results and observed damage patterns. These findings demonstrate the value of integrating OMA-based model updating with MCDM methods and support a data-driven framework for assessing the seismic performance of historical masonry structures.
Hakan Erkek (Tue,) studied this question.