The energy-dependent population of fine quantum states in single electron capture (SEC) reflects the intrinsic collision dynamics. Here we report experimental studies of Ar7+ ions colliding with He in the energy range of 1.05–17.5 keV/u. Owing to the high resolution of a recoil-ion momentum spectrometer, the n-, l-, and spin-state electron capture populations are well resolved, and a strong energy dependence of the SEC cross sections is observed. Most importantly, a clear inversion of the cross-section ratio between the spin-resolved triplet and singlet 3s3d configurations is found, demonstrating a breakdown of spin statistics. Together with recent spin-resolved studies of C3+-He collisions (PRL 133, 173002 (2024)), these results suggest that the breakdown of spin statistics is likely a general feature of charge exchange in open-shell highly charged ion systems.
Wu et al. (Wed,) studied this question.