Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article explores how obfuscation shapes Baloch experiences of military violence, indicating pathways to clarity and solidarity.
Pakistan's military has waged a decades-long campaign of violence against the Baloch, a marginalized and racialized group. This includes enforced disappearances, torture, targeted killings, and military raids, which intensified after 9/11 but are rooted in the colonial era, the formation of Pakistan, and Cold War counterinsurgencies. This article mobilizes “obfuscation” as an ethnographic concept to cohere a constellation of affects through which many Baloch have felt and made sense of this violence. It also traces how some have cultivated a clarity out of its midst. An affective lens reveals how emotions are not just responses to violence but integral to how it is lived, navigated, and resisted. The article challenges dominant reductions of violence in this region (and in other, similar southern sites of repression) to geopolitics, tribalism, ethnonationalism, and center-periphery conflict. Instead, it argues that felt obfuscation—deliberately produced by the state, and inherent to its rule—has refigured Baloch life through fragmentation or isolation while also, paradoxically, generating grounds for solidarities through intimacy. These contradictory effects have occasioned the making of a felt clarity now animating a mass movement led by Baloch women against military violence.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mahvish Ahmad (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: