New to Town: How Novice, Newcomer Teachers Approach Asset-Based, STEM Pedagogy in a Remote Montana Community

The purpose of this instrumental case study, employing both qualitative and quantitative data, was to investigate how novice teachers from non-local and urban areas used community assets and local funds of knowledge (FoK) in their STEM instruction in a remote Montana town. While non-local teachers often make up a large share of many rural communities’ teaching workforce, those teachers might lack the social, cultural, and community knowledge that they need to teach with place-conscious approaches. Therefore, this study explored how “new-to-town” teachers, with limited personal ties to a community, learn about their rural community and how they apply this knowledge to their teaching context. Additionally, this study examined which research-established factors that improve rural STEM education were deemed most important for novice, rural teachers. The exploration employed a floodlight research approach, whereby a census of the authentic pedagogical actions of the subjects was documented rather than investigating the efficacy of a single method. Data sources included qualitative instruments like concept maps and semi-structured interviews, alongside quantitative measures like ranked best-practices data and place-conscious lesson ratios, to provide both depth of interpretation and breadth of comparison across participants. Results from the deductive thematic analysis suggest that novice teachers aspire to implement asset-based pedagogical approaches in STEM instruction and possess some methods for integration but struggle to learn of local community assets without modeling and mentorship. Additionally, an unexpected pattern emerged from the findings: Novice, newcomer teachers that employed place-conscious lessons were more likely to remain teaching in their position. While this association cannot be interpreted causally, it might suggest that place-conscious mentorship practices may play a role in improving instruction and support the retention of non-local teachers in rural communities however, further, more robust exploration is warranted of this exploratory finding. Findings from this study can be used to inform recommendations for school districts, post-secondary institutions, and rural communities on how best to support beginning rural teachers with limited community connections.