This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
AbstractDoes women's representation influence foreign (aid) policy? And, if so, is this best explained as a function of women's unique values or attributable to the impact of greater gender equality? Building on previous work, we investigate whether women's greater presence in political life – evidence of greater gender equality – is associated with greater generosity, or whether women's values and (some) women's ability to influence policy as ministers affect aid's generosity. We find that women's representation in the parliament and in the cabinet is positively associated with a donor state's generosity, but that female ministers of foreign policy-related ministries do not influence the state's generosity. These findings suggest that gender equality is a more promising explanation for the generosity of states' foreign aid than women's values.Keywords: gender studiesinternational relationswomen and genderpolitical economy Notes1. We do not here address debates about the efficacy of aid to achieve this stated purpose. See e.g., Easterly (Citation2006) and Moyo (Citation2009).2. Following Breuning (Citation2001), we did a robustness check on a different measurement of gender equality. This measurement dichotomized the proportion of women in parliament into less and more than 30% women in parliament. Moreover, this paper also experimented with 25% as a threshold. We ran the same regression analysis with PCSEs and the results are quite consistent with using proportion of women in parliament as a measurement for gender equality. Please see Appendices A and B for the results.3. Koch and Fulton (Citation2011) use the "weighted mean score of the government, with each party's left-right score weighted by the percentage of seats it controls among all the parties in government. Positive numbers indicate more right-oriented governments, and negative numbers indicate more left-leaning governments" (13).4. Both GDP per capita and foreign trade as a proportion of GNI are calculated on the basis of data from the World Bank.5. Economic openness has been a commonly used control variable in foreign aid literature. Earlier studies assumed trade openness has a linear effect on foreign aid, such as Schraeder et al. (Citation1998). More recently, foreign aid literature prefer measuring trade openness by the trade policy index generated by Sachs and Warner (Citation1995), which is updated by Wacziarg and Welch (Citation2003). This index shows that trade openness is a dummy variable averaged over four years. There is a lack of study on a possible curve–linear relationship between trade openness and foreign aid.6. All donor states are fairly wealthy. The coefficient of variation for the "wealth" variable is only 0.2, which indicates low variation in this variable. However, this measure differentiates among global north countries, which are all wealthy if compared globally to other countries.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lu et al. (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: