Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In his classic study on Stanislaw II August, the last king of Poland (1764-1795), the French literary historian Jean Fabre observed in passing: "The attempt of Frank and his followers, which some hoped would bring about the mass conversion of the Jews, degenerated into an adventurer's undertaking, and his coreligionists reacted to it, for the most part, with indifference." 1 A number of scholars, thinkers and essayists in the twentieth-century, pre-eminently among them Gershom Scholem, have been fascinated with Jacob Frank's mystical-"heretical" movement, have tended to attach to it an enormous historical significance, and saw in virtually every trend which intended to launch Jewish history on a new course, in whatever direction, a late outgrowth that, at least in some sense, evolved out of it. Pawel Maciejko is skeptical of these claims, and entertains a more sober view of Frankism, close to that of the French critic: his book intends to explain why a deflationary assessment, and a rejection of those approaches which shower upon Frankism too much interpretation, are in order. The author has conducted extensive research, expounds in every chapter a well-crafted argument, and excels at combining narrative and analysis. These strengths will no doubt make of the book a near-classic, to which every interested historian will refer as to the up-to-date and reliable version of the history of the Frankist movement. It is then all the more urgent to ponder whether 1 See Jean Fabre, Stanislas-Auguste Poniatowski et l'Europe des Lumires (Strasbourg, 1952), 34: "La tentative de Frank et de ses adeptes, dont certains esprrent la conversion massive d'Isral, dgnre en quipe d'aventurier et laisse indiffrents la masse de ses coreligionnaires."
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Maurice Kriegel (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: