This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
The purpose of this study is to use a comparative approach to scrutinize the common assumption that certain school science activities are theoretical and therefore particularly suited for engaging students with scientific ideas, whereas others are practical and, thus, not equally conducive to engagement with scientific ideas. We compared two school science activities, one (laboratory work) that is commonly regarded as focusing attention on artefacts that may distract students from central science concepts and the other (concept mapping) that is thought to make students focus directly on these concepts. We observed students in either a laboratory activity about real galvanic cells or a concept-mapping activity about idealized galvanic cells. We used a practical epistemology analysis to compare the two activities regarding students' actions towards scientific ideas and artefacts. The comparison revealed that the two activities, despite their alleged differences along the theory–practice scale, primarily resulted in similar student actions. For instance, in both activities, students interacted extensively with artefacts and, to a lesser extent, with scientific ideas. However, only occasionally did students establish any explicit continuity between artefacts and scientific ideas. The findings indicate that some of the problems commonly considered to be unique for school science practical work may indeed be a feature of school science activities more generally. Keywords: Chemistry educationLaboratory workDiscourseConcept mappingHigh schoolLearning Notes Educational artefacts are also sometimes included in the concept of scaffolding (Granott, Citation2005; Sherin, Reiser, & Edelson, Citation2004). However, other authors make distinction between scaffolding as the variety of strategies employed by a teacher in her moment-by-moment interactions with the students, on the one hand, and the physical tools employed as part of realizing these strategies, on the other hand (Puntambekar & Hubscher, Citation2005; Sharpe, Citation2006). This distinction is retained in the present paper. There are two basic chemistry courses in the Swedish Natural Sciences Program, at the time labelled ‘Chemistry A’ and ‘Chemistry B’. Chemistry A is a general chemistry course, whereas the focus in Chemistry B is on organic chemistry, biochemistry, and analytic chemistry. The students of the present study were at the end of the course Chemistry A. The 23 electrochemistry terms provided were half cell, electrode, plus terminal, minus terminal, glass filter (salt bridge), current, voltage, circuit, charges, electrons, ions, positive ions, negative ions, oxidation, oxidize, reduction, reduce, noble, electronegative, chemical reaction, redox reaction, chemical energy, and electric energy. Obviously, in this excerpt, the students twice settled for the wrong explanation in support of the assembly of the cell. Thus, in lines 41–43, they incorrectly established that the galvanic cell would also work with separated beakers, and in lines 50–54, they established that there is no equivalent to a salt bridge in the galvanic cell in front of them. However, the analyses in this study are not dependent on whether the students came up with correct explanations or not. Here, the two students did indeed invoke the artefact to support scientific ideas although, this time, these ideas were not the correct ones.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hamza et al. (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: