Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Recreational hunting of game birds and mammals is globally widespread (Loveridge et al. 2009). Habitat and predator management is sometimes undertaken to increase game abundance and hunting bags (e.g. Hudson 1992, Arroyo et al. 2012). This can have environmental benefits such as creation and maintenance of wildlife-rich habitat (Potts 1986, Loveridge et al. 2009), but may conflict with delivering other ecosystem services and public benefits from the same landscapes (Côté et al. 2004). For these reasons, regulations to ensure responsible management and monitoring of game populations are widely recommended (Loveridge et al. 2009, Caro et al. 2014). Here we consider management for recreational shooting of Red Grouse Lagopus lagopus scotica, a subspecies of Willow Ptarmigan Lagopus lagopus that is endemic to submontane heathlands in the United Kingdom. The non-lekking, monogamous, highly territorial Willow Ptarmigan has a circumpolar distribution typically occurring at low breeding densities (0.1−10 pairs per km2) across northern Europe, northern Eurasia and North America (Watson & Moss 2008). However, in the UK intensive habitat management, predator control and medication are used to secure exceptionally high (150−500 birds per km2) post-breeding densities of Red Grouse, which are then driven (flushed) over static lines of shooters (Hudson 2008). This high-input, high-output management is practised in a regulatory environment in which landowners set their own bag limits and establish the management to deliver these, with the state only regulating quarry species, hunting season and permitted hunting methods. There is no statutory requirement for hunters to report their bags, although records are collected by a non-profit organization, the Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust (GWCT). This combination of intensive shooting practice with weak regulation is almost unique (Mustin et al. 2012), and offers general insights into the environmental impacts of intensive game management when managers operate without much of the regulation recommended by Loveridge et al. (2009). There is growing public debate about these impacts (Thompson et al. 2009, Avery 2015, Wightman & Tingay 2015), part of a wider trend of public engagement in hunting policy (Minnis 1998). For example, the recent near-extirpation of the Hen Harrier Circus cyaneus as a breeding bird in England (Redpath et al. 2010) and claims of mass culls of Mountain Hares Lepus timidus in Scotland by grouse moor managers (Anon 2014) has prompted three UK public petitions to license or ban driven grouse shooting, one for the introduction of vicarious liability (whereby the rights-holder is held responsible for the actions of an employee) and one for stronger legal protection of Scottish Mountain Hares, collectively amassing over 85 000 signatures by 29 January 2016. To date, however, wider environmental impacts of driven grouse management have received little public scrutiny, despite an increasing evidence base to inform a debate. Here we assess environmental impacts of driven grouse management and consider current regulation and policy in the context of the objective of securing legal and environmentally sustainable outcomes. Red Grouse depend on moorland habitats comprising blanket bog and heath beyond the altitudinal and climatic limits of enclosed agriculture (Watson & Moss 2008). These habitats and the breeding bird assemblages they support in the UK are of international conservation importance (Thompson et al. 1995), with large areas protected under national and international law. Moorlands also provide regulatory and cultural ecosystem services. The UK uplands are landscapes that inspire millions of people, with associated benefits for local economies, health and well-being. They provide 70% of drinking water in Britain, and support peatlands in England and Scotland that are the largest carbon store in the UK, amounting to almost 1800 Mt (Bonn et al. 2009, Chapman et al. 2009, Alonso et al. 2012). Driven shooting of Red Grouse on moorlands managed for the purpose is the economically dominant and most prestigious form of gamebird shooting in the UK (Hudson 1992, Sotherton et al. 2009). Grouse are driven by lines of ‘beaters’ to fly over a row of shooters who expect to kill more grouse in a day (30−40 each) than on a ‘walked-up’ shoot, where hunters walk in line using dogs to flush grouse. Most of this shooting takes place on private land. Fewer Red Grouse are now shot over a smaller land area than in the heyday of driven grouse shooting in the early 20th century (Hudson 1992). However, grouse shooting still takes place over approximately 850 000 ha (Douglas et al. 2015), with the intensity of management (number of gamekeepers employed, vegetation burning and grouse medication) increasing over the last 20−30 years (Natural England 2009, Clutterbuck & Yallop 2010). This reflects an industry choosing to intensify further to meet perceived market demands, with economic returns apparently reliant on producing ever more grouse (Osborne 2013). Annual monitoring of post-breeding Red Grouse densities by the GWCT on a sample of moors shows a 90% increase from 171 per km2 (1990−1994) to 325 per km2 (2010−2014) in England and a 74% increase from 81 to 141 per km2 over the same period in Scotland, with the rapid increase attributed to higher strengths of medicated grit to combat strongyle worm infections in grouse (Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust 2015). In places, Red Grouse are now more abundant than at any time since the 1930s (Osborne 2013). Gamekeepers kill predators of grouse to maximize the shootable surplus. Red Foxes Vulpes vulpes, Stoats Mustela erminea, Weasels Mustela nivalis and some corvid Corvus species are legally shot and trapped. However, illegal trapping, shooting and poisoning of protected birds of prey and mammalian predators also takes place and limits the national range and population size of some species (Whitfield et al. 2003, Redpath et al. 2010, Amar et al. 2012). Red Grouse feed mainly on young, nutritious Heather Calluna vulgaris shoot tips and use older, deeper Heather for nesting and protective cover. Vegetation is burned on rotation (every 10−30 years) to create and maintain a mosaic of different ages of Heather and other dwarf shrubs to benefit grouse (Hudson 1992). Managed burning also maintains open habitats by inhibiting woodland regeneration. Reductions in grazing densities of sheep and deer and control of Bracken Pteridium aquilinum by herbicide spraying are also used to maintain Heather dominance (Grant et al. 2012). Red Grouse are vulnerable to strongylosis, a disease caused by the gastrointestinal nematode Trichostrongylus tenuis which depresses body condition, may cause death, and can reduce brood sizes and population densities (Redpath et al. 2006). Following trials (Newborn & Foster 2002), Red Grouse are now routinely treated with anti-worming drugs (flubendazole) by medication of grit, which the birds take to aid digestion of Heather. This medicated grit, including ‘super-strength’ varieties (Osborne 2013), is dispensed from boxes typically located 100−200 m apart across the moor (i.e. one box per territory). Red Grouse are also susceptible to louping-ill, a virus causing encephalomyelitis in sheep that is also carried by wild mammals such as hares and deer, and is transmitted by the tick Ixodes ricinus (Watson & Moss 2008). To reduce the infection risk from louping-ill, some gamekeepers treat sheep with acaricides which can reduce tick burdens by 90% and also shoot Mountain Hares and Red Deer Cervus elaphus (Watson & Moss 2008, Newborn & Baines 2012). Control of corvids, foxes and mustelids can increase the breeding success and abundance of other ground-nesting birds, including Northern Lapwing Vanellus vanellus, European Golden Plover Pluvialis apricaria and Eurasian Curlew Numenius arquata (e.g. Tharme et al. 2001, Fletcher et al. 2010), as well as Red Grouse. However, protected raptors, mammalian predators such as Wildcats Felis silvestris, Badgers Meles meles, Pine Martens Martes martes and even domestic cats are regularly killed illegally (Harris & Yalden 2008, RSPB 2015). The impacts on raptors have received the most attention. For example, Managed burning has helped to protect dwarf-shrub heath from increasing grazing pressure and afforestation (Robertson et al. 2001), and can provide good habitat for some birds of high conservation importance, including Eurasian Curlew and European Golden Plover (Thompson et al. 1995, Tharme et al. 2001). However, burning reduces availability of nesting cover for species using deep Heather (e.g. Merlin Falco columbarius, Hen Harrier and Short-eared Owl Asio flammeus) and dominant Heather cover disfavours species associated with grassy moorland such as Skylark Alauda arvensis and Meadow Pipit Anthus pratensis (Tharme et al. 2001, Pearce-Higgins & Grant 2006), and prevents successional recovery of scrub and woodland and its associated biodiversity (Watson & Moss 2008). On grouse moors, burning rotations are becoming shorter, the number of annual burns is increasing, and moorlands overlying deep peat soils that often support blanket bog and wet heath are routinely burned (Yallop et al. 2006, Douglas et al. 2015). This occurs on protected areas, despite government regulation to prevent damage to mire and woodland habitat, soils and water (e.g. Scottish Government 2011; see Appendix S1), and the fact that repeated burning of blanket bog is inconsistent with international responsibilities to maintain and restore blanket bog to favourable conservation status. As a result, only 14% of UK upland peatland habitats are in favourable condition (Committee on Climate Change 2015) because burning of blanket bog and wet heath can lead to long-term loss of bog-forming Sphagnum mosses in favour of Heather or grass and sedge cover, especially when combined with stressors such as grazing and atmospheric pollution (Glaves et al. 2013). The result is degradation or loss of peat formation and carbon sink conditions (Garnett et al. 2000, Ward et al. 2007). The long-term effect of burning on below-ground carbon processes remains unclear. On Heather-dominated peatlands, vigorous re-growth of young Heather after burning may yield increased net uptake of carbon, but more carbon is stored in the peat than in the vegetation, thus favouring the restoration of Calluna-dominated ecosystems back to their original, Sphagnum-dominated, peat-forming state (Clay et al. 2015). Peatland restoration may also be a more sustainable long-term means to achieving another often-claimed benefit of prescribed burning on grouse moors: the reduction of wildfire risk (e.g. McMorrow et al. 2009). Increasingly, evidence suggests that many wildfires have impacts not much different from those of prescribed burns, with many wildfires arising from prescribed burns (reviewed by Werritty et al. 2015). Burning also has hydrological impacts with associated economic consequences. It can cause elevated dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and water discoloration, whose remedial treatment costs are then borne by water companies and their customers (Grayson et al. 2012). The removal of surface vegetation also increases runoff so that in the most intense rainfall events flow peaks downstream are exacerbated (Holden et al. 2015). In the long term, temperature-driven drying and wetting cycles near the surface of burned and exposed peat increase the potential of DOC leaching for up to 10−20 years (Holden et al. 2014, Brown et al. 2015), and macro-invertebrate diversity of rivers can be reduced in burned catchments (Brown et al. 2013). Treatment of Red Grouse with anthelminthics via medicated grit or direct dosing is routine (Newborn & Foster 2002). However, there is no clear evidence that culling Mountain Hares increases Red Grouse densities and both ticks and louping-ill virus persist even when tick hosts occur at very low densities (Gilbert et al. 2001, Harrison et al. 2010), so the scientific case for culling Mountain Hares is weak (Werritty et al. 2015). The impacts of these practices on Mountain Hare populations and the wider environmental impacts of acaricides and anthelminthic treatments remain unknown. However, laboratory studies show that aquatic toxicities of benzimidazole anthelminthics, including flubendazole, to bacteria and invertebrates are sufficient to indicate potential wider environmental problems (Oh et al. 2006), thus reflecting broader concerns about the environmental impacts and weak regulation of veterinary pharmaceuticals (Margalida et al. 2014). These impacts can in some circumstances be severe, as shown by the recent catastrophic declines of Gyps vulture populations across the Indian subcontinent, caused by toxicity of a non-steroidal anti-inflammtory drug, diclofenac, in the tissues of the cattle on which the vultures fed (Green et al. 2004). Lastly, the incidence of a new disease in Red Grouse, respiratory cryptosporidiosis, caused by Cryptosporidium baileyi, has increased markedly since it was first observed in northern England in 2010, and may now have started to affect Black Grouse Tetrao tetrix (Baines et al. 2014), a species of conservation concern. The spread of cryptosporidiosis in grouse may be a consequence of high population densities, increased risk of cross-infection at grit-feeding stations or infected birds being driven over several kilometres across lines of shooters (Osborne 2013, Baines et al. 2014). Red Grouse shooting as currently practised has some environmental benefits, notably for maintenance of Heather moorland and some ground-nesting birds, especially waders. However, there is growing evidence of negative environmental impacts and societal costs associated with increasingly intensive management practices, many of which are not usually factored in to studies (e.g. Sotherton et al. 2009) of the economics of driven grouse management. Overall, there is increasing evidence that driven grouse shooting is incompatible with requirements for the hunting of Annex II species (e.g. Red Grouse) under Article 7 of the EU Birds Directive, including the principles of wise use and requirement not to jeopardize conservation efforts. This principle is defined for wetlands, including peatlands, as ‘the maintenance of their ecological character, achieved through the implementation of ecosystem approaches, within the context of sustainable development’ (Ramsar Convention Secretariat 2007). Following these principles, land use and management, including those for Red Grouse shooting, would need to deliver a range of ecosystem services and help biodiversity recover and adapt to climate change. Grouse moor management could contribute by developing and promoting alternative shooting styles and cultures (e.g. walked-up shooting or driven shooting of smaller bags) which integrate more readily with wider environmental and societal objectives for sustainable moorland management. For this to happen, a fundamental shift in behaviours and practices would be needed, informed by evidence, supported by public policy, and led by landowners committed to a sustainable future for grouse shooting. In the 1930s, Aldo Leopold, a founding father of the science of wildlife management, observed that game management for recreational shooting should ‘grow natural species in an environment not greatly altered for the purpose in hand, relying on partial control of a few factors to enhance the yield above what unguided nature would produce… controls are barely visible; an observer, unless he were an expert, could see no difference between managed and unmanaged terrain’, and concluded that ‘the recreational value of a head of game is inverse to the artificiality of its origin, and hence to the intensiveness of the system of game management which produced it’ (Leopold 1933). Driven grouse moor management has diverged far from these principles, but they would serve well as principles of environmentally sustainable grouse moor management. A pioneering example of an attempt to deliver a wider range of ecosystem benefits from a former grouse moor is the Langholm Moor Demonstration Project in southwest Scotland, a partnership between the landowner, conservation charities and statutory organizations. After 8 years, this project has reduced grazing pressures, halted Heather loss, seen increases in populations of Black Grouse and Hen Harriers, and restored Red Grouse densities to those that last supported grouse shooting (Langholm Moor Demonstration Project 2014). It has also successfully adopted diversionary feeding of nesting Hen Harriers (Redpath et al. 2001) to reduce predatory impacts on grouse. But such initiatives remain the exception. For example, the recently published action plan for Hen Harriers in England (Defra 2016) focuses on the conflict with driven grouse shooting rather than addressing the underlying environmental impacts of driven grouse management. In a recent review, Werritty et al. (2015) found strong evidence of deterioration of moorland habitats and urged the need for a shared vision to tackle these problems. The range and abundance declines of many upland breeding birds in the UK revealed by the recent Bird Atlas (Balmer et al. 2013) are examples of the severity of the challenge. Reforms of grouse moor management could be central to this vision, but inability or unwillingness to self-regulate, especially in regard to the evidence of killing of protected raptors and burning on deep peat, is driving increasingly vocal and publicly supported calls to ban driven grouse shooting (e.g. Avery 2015). Statutory regulation and effective legislative deterrence of illegal management could catalyse more fundamental reform, and this would need to be accompanied by further research to tackle remaining evidence needs. These include (i) the wider environmental impacts of acaricides and anthelminthics, and lead shot (Group of Scientists 2014) currently used on grouse moors, (ii) the long-term impacts of repeated rotational burning of above-ground vegetation on the peat carbon cycle, and on riparian biodiversity, (iii) analyses of the economic contribution of driven grouse management which take full account of externalized environmental costs, and (iv) understanding the effects of land use patterns and loss of apex predators on populations of bird and mammal predators of Red Grouse. We are grateful to RSPB Trustees and colleagues for discussions and contributions to this work, and to Arjun Amar for improving an earlier version of the manuscript. P.S.T. undertook a review of the literature while on sabbatical. Please note: The publisher is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thompson et al. (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: