Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
BRITISH DEMOCRACY reached an ugly moment on 3 November 2016, when the Daily Mail and Daily Telegraph, the country's leading press representatives of conservative opinion, devoted their front pages to displaying photographs of three judges of the Supreme Court under the banner headlines, respectively, 'Enemies of the people' and 'The judges vs the people'.The judges' offence had been to rule that Parliament had a right to have certain votes on the process of the United Kingdom leaving the European Union (EU).In subsequent days some government ministers echoed the phrases, until the Home Secretary, under pressure from judges, issued a statement stressing the importance of the rule of law.However, the government itself continued in the same spirit when it attempted later to rule that, because a majority in the referendum on EU membership had voted to leave, none of the individual measures it would implement in order to revoke EU legislation-ranging across virtually all fields of policy-needed to come to Parliament.The people had spoken; government would interpret their will.Parliament, it seemed, like the Supreme Court, was a potential enemy of that will.This was a confrontation between two concepts of democracy: does it (as in liberal democracy) denote a set of institutions that include expressions of popular will, but which surround them with others that ensure elaboration of that will, guarantee continued debate so that democracy can function again at a future date, and even limit the powers of those who claim the right to exercise the popular will?Or is it (as in populist democracy) the direct, unmediated voice of a people expressed on a particular day?This confrontation is by no means limited to the UK or to the Brexit debate, and it is a very old theme in democratic theory.In practice, the countries that are normally regarded as stable democracies have resolved the conflict in favour of the former concept.So well established did it seem that in 1992, the US political scientist Francis Fukuyama earned lasting renown for arguing that in western liberal democracy, humankind had reached the summit of its social evolution. 1That questioning the viability of liberal democracy is now a live issue requires understanding.Equally intriguing is that fact that attacks on it from the political right, more or less silent since the fall of the Portuguese and Spanish fascist regimes in the 1970s, have returned to prominence across large parts of the world.The Marxist left has long been suspicious of liberal democracy, sometimes advocating the 'people's democracy' considered to have been achieved in the state socialist societies.Since their collapse, the left had retreated into utopian dreaming, but has more recently seen new opportunities in the waves of populism, even though these are mainly being led from the right.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Colin Crouch (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: