Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The ASLO 2023 Aquatic Sciences Meeting took place 4 to 9 June in Palma, Spain. The theme, resilience and recovery, applies to the natural world and our lives. Adaptability to disruptions is a valuable trait for early career researchers (ECRs), as they must deal with various barriers to success. We introduced ECRs to initiatives aimed at overcoming these barriers—the ASLO Raelyn Cole Editorial Fellowship and associated opportunities. The Fellowship enables ECRs to develop scientific publishing skills as authors, peer reviewers, and editorial board members. It also fosters personal growth, contributing to resilience in academia, and exchange of lessons with peers. Approximately 30 ECRs attended the session; below we briefly describe the Fellowship's origin, lessons learnt by the Fellows, and topics of interest from the audience. This Fellowship honors Raelyn Cole (Managing Editor of Limnology and Oceanography from 1965 to 1996) and her long and productive scientific career. After Raelyn's passing, her husband Dale approached ASLO to establish an endowment in her name; Teresa Curto, ASLO's executive director, suggested a scientific publishing fellowship for ECRs. The Fellowship started in 2017, funded by Dale's initial and ongoing donations, as well as ASLO's matching contributions. Limnology & Oceanography Letters (LOL) currently hosts the program, whose structure was developed by founding Editor-in-Chief (EiC) Pat Soranno and the first Fellow Laura Falkenberg. This two-year program selects applicants to work alongside the EiC of LOL, who encourages them to explore personal interests in any aspect of scientific publishing. For details on the Fellowship, see https://www.aslo.org/opportunities-in-aslo/raelyn-cole-editorial-fellowship/. I was the inaugural Fellow, so my term was initially about working with then EiC Pat Soranno to identify how the program would run and achieve its goals of exposing Fellows to scientific publishing, peer review, and editorial workflow, as well as enable them to disseminate understanding to their peers. Over the two years, I shared my experience in better understanding the process of peer review—and publishing more broadly—through blog posts (https://www.aslo.org/category/rcef/), publications (Falkenberg and Soranno 2018; Poulson-Ellestad et al. 2020), and workshops run at various conferences. A key aspect I've enjoyed about the Fellowship—both during and after my term—is the community and relationships I've gained. This includes ASLO broadly (I remain actively involved as EiC of L&O Bulletin), and the other Fellows, some of whom are introduced below (Fig. 1). With so many peers on a path to academic overachievement or whose parents were professors, I always felt behind the curve. I wanted to show others that academia doesn't have to be a struggle; a skill can, in some cases, save a career. As a fellow, I wrote an article about concise scientific writing (Hotaling 2020), which is ASLO's most downloaded article of all-time. I also used the fellowship to create opportunities by starting the L&O Letters Early Career Publication Honor (ECPH) alongside Fellows Kelsey Poulson-Ellestad, Bridget Deemer, and L&O Letters EiC Jim Cloern (see Hotaling et al. 2023). Being Brazilian, I am personally aware of the extra barriers faced by Global South ECRs in science and have tried to empower them through my Fellowship. I'm fortunate to lead the 2022 ECPH, which hopes to highlight the often under looked Global South ECR science (Dextro 2023). I'm also trying to expose these ECRs to worldwide opportunities, and to hold workshops on scientific writing and reviewing in Portuguese/Spanish. I am just starting my Fellowship journey and have already gained much from the experience. I have expanded my understanding about the process of and issues surrounding peer-review through discussions with Jim, Rita, and past Fellows. In the coming years, I will explore barriers to open access publishing. Application calls occur biennially, and we were asked why not annually. Two years was perceived as a long time to wait, especially if one misses a call, potentially disqualifying ECRs bordering the mid-career stage. While that is true, each call selects two Fellows who start one year apart, guaranteeing two overlapping Fellows in any given year so that one may provide guidance to the other. The call schedule also depends on the EiC's availability to mentor Fellows. We were also asked about the strictness of the selection criteria. Some are flexible, such as the ECR definition—a researcher up to 10 years post-terminal degree. Career breaks, such as employment outside of academia or medical leave, are considered in addition to this time. Other criteria, such as a minimum number of first author publications and peer reviews conducted, are stricter, as they intend to select applicants with the scientific publishing experience required for conducting the projects expected of Fellows. If in doubt, contact the EiC (according to call instructions) prior to applying. Annually, Fellows receive a stipend ($1500), ASLO membership, and travel support for one ASLO-sponsored conference and the Wiley Editors' Strategy Day. A member of the audience noted that this “remuneration” was not that of a full-time job and wanted to know about Fellows' time commitment. We collectively chose to commit our time because of the personal and professional experiences and skills gained, and for our passion to serve our community and help ECRs. We've published several papers related to the Fellowship (see the LOL virtual issue “Celebration of Contributions from ASLO's Raelyn Cole Editorial Fellows”, https://aslopubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/toc/10.1002/(ISSN)2378-2242.RCE-fellows) and engaged in ECR-targeted activities: created and led calls to provide publication waivers (ECPH), provided friendly reviews, and organized and led conference sessions and writing/reviewing workshops. There is no formal time commitment; it depends on one's interests and developmental stages of projects, being heavier at times and slower at others. Time-tracking was raised by Erin, who shared her use of the app Toggle to manage tasks and, thus, free up her schedule for Fellowship-related activities. During his introduction, Scott touched on his personal motivation for applying: he was a (self-proclaimed) mediocre graduate student who did not publish until late in his PhD. Before writing his first paper he often contemplated what to do with his career, since academia was not it. He persevered to write that first paper, expecting it to go slowly. Much to his (and his advisor's) surprise, writing seemed to come naturally. Bolstered by positive feedback, he spent more time writing and published >10 papers during the last two years of his PhD. Discovering his academic superpower (writing) was a boon to his career. The audience was intrigued by the topic and suggested that the Fellows organize a workshop on “How to find your academic superpower. They were also curious about the other Fellows' superpowers (Laura is a prolific writer, Rita gets things done, and Erin excels at time-tracking); and wondered if all superpowers are welcome in the Fellowship. Yes, skill diversity is key, as it helps the Fellows connect to their ECR peers. Someone asked if it would be possible to be better at speaking than writing and still be selected as a Fellow—speaking skills are much appreciated in the Fellowship, and we think it is probably easier to learn how to write academically than how to speak confidently. We also noted that writing is made easier by first presenting data, even if only to yourself. Concerns were raised about potential disadvantages to applicants who speak English as a foreign language (EFL), and whether ASLO supports EFL ECRs. Applications to the Fellowship are encouraged from all, and being an EFL speaker is a strength in many ways. As the first EFL Fellow, Rita has dedicated her Fellowship to help others break the language barrier in academic publishing. She attended the Latin American Ocean Sciences Meeting (COLACMAR) in 2022, during which she hosted a workshop in Spanish on how to write a paper. There, she also connected with ECRs and shared opportunities for career development, while engaging them to form a group of Latin American ECRs in Ocean Sciences. ASLO journals have a society-minded way of working and strive to help authors, especially ECRs, overcome challenges to publication. While there is no formal system in place, support can be found—we expect many ASLO members would happily donate their time to language-edit manuscripts from EFL applicants. This is already done, for example, in the context of the ECPH. The audience also wanted to know how ECRs can get invited to peer review for a journal. We have three suggestions: (1) join the ASLO Peer Review ECR list (https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdoIiMA_jgz60IiPLR0v0rA5xY2KmQHGnORts8ZCo-AxJVnkQ/viewform), which feeds into Scholar One, the platform used by associate editors to invite reviewers; (2) create an author profile for your journal of choice—editors will link your expertise to relevant manuscripts; and (3) self-nominate as reviewer for preferred journals which offer that option (e.g., Royal Society - https://forms.royalsociety.org/s/RFvolunteers2021). Laura, L&O Bulletin Editor, was asked about the journal scope and article length for L&O Bulletin submissions. For those wishing to submit, relevant information is available at: https://aslopubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/hub/journal/15396088/about/author-guidelines. We biasedly encourage ECRs to apply for the Fellowship! Follow our X/Twitter account (@rcef_aslo) for upcoming calls. For questions, email us at [email protected]. RMFS, EP, and SH were fully supported by ASLO and the Raelyn Cole Editorial Fellowship to travel to ASM for this session. We also acknowledge Dale Cole and family, who generously support the Raelyn Cole Editorial Fellowship under which this manuscript was developed. LJF is Editor of Limnology and Oceanography Bulletin. The authors declare that they have no other competing interests.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Franco-Santos et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: