Planar microwave (MW) sensors offer high-resolution, non-invasive technology for monitoring critical soil properties, serving as a support for modern precision agriculture. While laboratory studies confirm their exceptional sensitivity, the widespread adoption of these sensors is severely impeded by critical translational challenges that constitute a defining “lab-to-field gap”. These barriers include high sensor-to-sensor variability, debilitating thermal cross-sensitivity, soil heterogeneity necessitating unique site-specific calibration, and the enduring tension between high-performance and cost-effective scaling. This review systematically synthesizes the current state of planar permittivity MW technology, moving beyond technical mechanisms to critically assess these operational limitations. We detail advanced architectural strategies designed to bridge this gap, focusing particularly on the transition toward more robust solutions. The key strategies analyzed include the adoption of differential sensor designs using microstrip patch antennas to mitigate common-mode environmental errors, the integration of ultra-compact metamaterial structures such as split-ring resonators (SRRs) and complementary split-ring resonators (CSRRs) for enhanced field robustness and deep soil sensing, and the necessity of multi-parameter sensing capabilities (moisture, pH, and salinity). By establishing a comprehensive roadmap that prioritizes field stability, cost efficiency, and seamless IoT integration, this review demonstrates that planar MW sensors are poised to become reliable and scalable tools. Addressing these critical translational hurdles will ensure optimal resource management, significantly enhance crop productivity, and enable sustainable practices within smart farming ecosystems.
Alduwish et al. (Sat,) studied this question.