Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Quasi-experimental study finds guided ventilation improves performance in ICU clinicians, suggesting better outcomes.
• Although manual bag ventilation is routine in ICU, clinicians may not achieve established targets in everyday practice. • ICU nurses and intensivists failed to deliver optimal ventilation during standard self-guided manual ventilation. • The use of a hand-held ventilation feedback device significantly improved the quality of manual ventilation. • Ventilation sequences with both V T and V R within the target range were only achieved during the guided tests. Manual bag ventilation is a routine procedure in the intensive care unit. It is neither simple nor free from adverse events. To compare standard manual ventilation with ventilation guided by a ventilation feedback device in terms of bag ventilation delivery by intensive care unit clinicians. In this quasi-experimental study with non-concurrent controls intensive care unit clinicians delivered usual-care manual bag ventilations via an endotracheal tube to adult mechanically ventilated patients without or with non-severe respiratory pathology. Each participant performed one unguided trial and one ventilation feedback device-guided trial. The variables analysed were median tidal volume, median minute ventilation, and median ventilation rate. Adequate ventilation performance was defined as a median tidal volume (4–8 mL/Kg predicted body weight) and a median ventilation rate (8–13 min −1 ) within the target range. Fifty-three intensive care unit clinicians performed, in total, 106 manual ventilation trials: 53 unguided and 53 ventilation feedback device-guided. Under unguided conditions, intensive care unit clinicians failed to deliver standard manual ventilation within the appropriate parameters, with both tidal volume and ventilation rate falling outside the target range. Ventilation performance improved during ventilation feedback device-guided trials, with both tidal volume and minute ventilation fell significantly more frequently within the target range ( p < 0.001). In patients with pulmonary pathology, ventilation feedback device guidance was associated with significantly lower ventilation rate ( p = 0.02) and minute ventilation ( p < 0.001). Without real-time feedback, intensive care unit clinicians appear unable to deliver optimal ventilation when performing usual-care standard manual ventilation. The use of a hand-held portable ventilation feedback device may help to improve manual bag ventilation at bedside.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rodríguez‐Ruiz et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: