Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This analysis proposes a topological symmetry to resolve the strong CP problem, predicting neutron EDM constraints and axion non-existence.
The strong CP problem is among the most durable puzzles of the Standard Model. Quantum chromodynamics admits a CP-violating term in its Lagrangian proportional to a parameter θ_QCD that could a priori take any value in [0, 2π); neutron electric-dipole-moment measurements constrain it to |θ_QCD| < 10^(-10) (Abel et al. 2020; PDG 2024). The Standard Model offers no explanation for the extreme smallness of this parameter. The conventional resolution is the Peccei–Quinn mechanism (Peccei & Quinn 1977): a new global U(1) symmetry that is spontaneously broken, producing a pseudo-Goldstone boson (the axion) that dynamically relaxes θ_QCD to zero. Despite fifty years of searches (ADMX, HAYSTAC, CAPP, CASPEr, IAXO, and more), no axion has been found. We show that in the Three Time Dimensions (3+3) spacetime framework (de Haan 2026, book manuscript, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19633127), in which the third time dimension t3 is compactified as a discrete two-sphere S^2 with 2^152 Planck-area cells, the strong CP problem is resolved by a topological symmetry that requires no new particles: the Z3 trisection symmetry of S^2 forces θ_QCD = 0 exactly, as a symmetry statement. The three trisection sectors at azimuths phi = 0, 120, 240 degrees must be topologically equivalent; the parameter θ_QCD is the relative phase between them; a non-zero value would break the equivalence. Because Z3 is forced by the Euler–Poincaré constraint on a hex-pentagon tiling of S^2 (which gives exactly 12 pentagonal defects in a cuboctahedral arrangement, forcing a trisection with N_c(N_c+1) = 12 and therefore N_c = 3), the symmetry is topological, not dynamical. No Peccei–Quinn mechanism is needed; no axion is predicted to exist. The framework makes two firm empirical commitments. First, it predicts that no axion will ever be detected at any mass and any coupling consistent with the Peccei–Quinn relation m_a proportional to 1/f_a. Every null result from ADMX, HAYSTAC, CAPP, CASPEr, IAXO, and future axion searches is consistent with the framework. An axion discovery at any experiment falsifies the topological resolution. Second, it predicts that the neutron electric dipole moment receives only weak-sector contributions, d_n ~ 10^(-31) e.cm, far below the current PSI 2020 bound of 1.8e-26 e.cm but within reach of the n2EDM and SNS nEDM experiments in the late 2020s. A measured non-zero EDM above ~10^(-29) e.cm with confirmed strong-CP origin would falsify the topological resolution. This paper is self-contained. It recapitulates the topological chain from the Euler characteristic of S^2 to the Z3 trisection in full, presents the QCD-vacuum-as-flat-connections identification, derives θ_QCD = 0 from the Z3 symmetry, explains why the Peccei–Quinn mechanism becomes unnecessary, and discusses the wider elegance claim that the same Z3 symmetry solves four long-standing Standard Model problems simultaneously: N_c = 3 colours, three fermion generations, the lepton CP phase δ_PMNS, and θ_QCD = 0. One topological symmetry, four puzzles dissolved.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
C. R. (René) de Haan (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: