Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Research demonstrates the negative impact of infant mortality and ethnic fragmentation on democracy, suggesting modernization theory needs reassessment.
Modernization theory proposes that social and economic conditions can significantly support higher levels of democracy or democratization. The theory argues that a larger national income, improved social conditions, and a reduction in ethnic divisions are the socio-economic foundations of democracy. Does modernization theory still have any validity today? Our research re-tests several hypotheses drawn from the modernization theory, using Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem) data to account for democracy, democratization, upswings, and downturns. The hypotheses test whether more national income, less infant mortality, lower fertility rates, more education, and/or less ethnic fractionalization will increase indicators of democracy and democratization. We use a dataset containing information about 151 countries (including 101 developing countries), spanning years from 1970 to 2019. In our tests, two-way fixed effects models on time-series cross-sectional (TSCS) data employ the hypothesized social and economic variables and lagged dependent variables in the same model to determine which conditions have the most influence. More ethnic fractionalization has a significant and negative effect on levels of democracy. Higher levels of infant mortality have a significant and negative effect on levels of democracy using V-Dem data. Higher fertility rates have a significant and negative effect on levels of democracy if infant mortality is left out, suggesting some collinearity between infant mortality and fertility rates. Indicators such as national income and education are not statistically relevant or fail to have the predicted effect. We also perform robustness tests using Polity V data in place of V-Dem data. Tests on Polity V data broadly confirm our results with V-Dem data. We find no significant results for tests on reverse causation, indicating that endogeneity may not be driving the original results. Our results confirm the current contention that economic development alone is not sufficient for democracy. Our results do indicate that for democracy to thrive, ethnic fragmentation within a country needs to be managed to encourage a healthy coexistence between different ethnic groups. Levels of democracy may also improve with contributions to women's social standing and health. Efforts at consolidating democracy may still benefit from emphasizing these improvements.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hall et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: