Key result
Martin/Hopkins and direct LDL-C outperform Friedewald with up to ~86% agreement at elevated triglycerides.
Why the study?
Do newer LDL-C estimation equations (Martin/Hopkins, Sampson) or direct measurement reduce misclassification compared to the Friedewald formula across different triglyceride strata?
Observational (n=1,289)
No
Do newer LDL-C estimation equations (Martin/Hopkins, Sampson) or direct measurement reduce misclassification compared to the Friedewald formula across different triglyceride strata?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Friedewald formula demonstrates poor agreement and high misclassification rates at moderately elevated triglyceride levels, supporting the use of Martin/Hopkins, Sampson, or direct LDL-C measurement to guide lipid-lowering therapy.
Low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) is central to cardiovascular risk assessment, yet its accurate determination remains challenging. The Friedewald formula performs poorly in hypertriglyceridemia, while newer formulas such as Martin/Hopkins and Sampson show improved accuracy. In Uganda and sub-Saharan Africa, contemporary comparisons of these equations against direct assays are lacking, increasing the risk of misclassification. We conducted a retrospective method comparison study at Sebbi Hospital, Uganda, analyzing 1,289 lipid profiles (2022–2025). Directly measured LDL-C on the Mindray BS-230 analyzer was compared with Friedewald, Martin/Hopkins, and Sampson formula-calculated LDL-C. Agreement, correlation, root mean square error (RMSE), mean absolute difference (MAD), and misclassification at European Society of Cardiology/European Atherosclerosis Society (ESC/EAS) treatment thresholds were assessed across triglyceride strata (<150, 150–399, ≥400 mg/dL). For TG <150 mg/dL, all methods showed comparable agreement with the Sampson equation (84.13 – 85.03%, k=0.696 – 0.706), with misclassification rates of 14.97 – 15.87% and MAD ranging from 13.87 to 15.54 mg/dL. For TG 150 - 399 mg/dL, agreement declined markedly for Friedwald (67.75%), but remained substantially higher for directly measured LDL-C(86.07%) and Martin/Hopkins (82.12%). Misclassification was highest for Friedwald (32.43%) compared with Martin/Hopkins (17.88%) and directly measured LDL-C (13.93%). For TG≥400 mg/dL, agreement was nominally high for directly measured LDL-C (78.79) but weighted kappa was poor and non-significant for all three methods. MAD was 57.56mg/dL for directly measured LDL-C, 103.45mg/dL for Friedwald and 64.96mg/dL for Martin/Hopkins, with over 93% of directly measured LDL-C values differing from Sampson-calculated values by more than 20mg/dL. Agreement and misclassification varied by triglycerides level, with all methods showing comparable concordance with Sampson equation in the low-TG stratum. Friedwald equation showed the poorest agreement and highest misclassification at moderately elevated triglycerides level. In severe hypertriglyceridemia, large differences were observed across all methods, though conclusions were limited y small sample size. Findings highlight the importance of transparent reporting of LDL-C measurement method and careful interpretation near ESC/EAS treatment thresholds.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jonani et al. (2026) conducted an observational in Cardiovascular risk assessment (lipid profiling) (n=1,289). Directly measured LDL-C vs. Friedewald, Martin/Hopkins, and Sampson formula-calculated LDL-C was evaluated on Agreement and misclassification at ESC/EAS treatment thresholds across triglyceride strata. Directly measured LDL-C and Martin/Hopkins equation showed higher agreement than the Friedewald formula for LDL-C estimation at moderately elevated triglycerides.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: