Why the study?
To determine how many incidentally detected cases of left ventricular noncompaction meeting the Petersen criterion were truly abnormal by analyzing short-axis CMR images and applying 3 other published diagnostic criteria.
Do different CMR diagnostic criteria yield different prevalence estimates for left ventricular noncompaction in a pediatric screening cohort?
Do different CMR diagnostic criteria yield different prevalence estimates for left ventricular noncompaction in a pediatric screening cohort?
Different CMR diagnostic criteria for left ventricular noncompaction yield widely varying prevalence estimates in a pediatric screening cohort, suggesting many cases meeting initial criteria may be normal anatomic variants.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
LVNC prevalence varies widely by CMR criterion in pediatric screening; leaves open optimal thresholds and should not yet change practice.
In a previous cross-sectional screening study of 5,169 middle and high school students (mean age, 13.1 ± 1.78 yr) in which we estimated the prevalence of high-risk cardiovascular conditions associated with sudden cardiac death, we incidentally detected by cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) 959 cases (18.6%) of left ventricular noncompaction (LVNC) that met the Petersen diagnostic criterion (noncompaction:compaction ratio >2.3). Short-axis CMR images were available for 511 of these cases (the Short-Axis Study Set). To determine how many of those cases were truly abnormal, we analyzed the short-axis images in terms of LV structural and functional variables and applied 3 published diagnostic criteria besides the Petersen criterion to our findings. The estimated prevalences were 17.5% based on trabeculated LV mass (Jacquier criterion), 7.4% based on trabeculated LV volume (Choi criterion), and 1.3% based on trabeculated LV mass and distribution (Grothoff criterion). Absent longitudinal clinical outcomes data or accepted diagnostic standards, our analysis of the screening data from the Short-Axis Study Set did not definitively differentiate normal from pathologic cases. However, it does suggest that many of the cases might be normal anatomic variants. It also suggests that cases marked by pathologically excessive LV trabeculation, even if asymptomatic, might involve unsustainable physiologic disadvantages that increase the risk of LV dysfunction, pathologic remodeling, arrhythmias, or mural thrombi. These disadvantages may escape detection, particularly in children developing from prepubescence through adolescence. Longitudinal follow-up of suspected LVNC cases to ascertain their natural history and clinical outcome is warranted.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Masso et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: