Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To what extent are our practices consistent with values that we espouse? --R. A. Smith Introduction This article explores intersection of ethics and professionalism in academia. Specifically, we examine what it means to be both ethical and professional as an academician. Although we focus primarily upon college and university faculty members, we believe that our observations and conclusions have relevance for broader range of roles and actors in academic community. We begin by addressing importance of ethics both as a topic and a practice within academy. We then discuss nature of good citizenship and professionalism and how these concepts translate into academic world. Models of professorate are also offered. We then offer a definition and typology of ethics failure in academia and show how these are linked to professionalism. Finally, we explore ways in which academic organizations can respond to such failure. The central questions guiding this article are: What does it mean to be a professional academic? What is nature of moral failure within this profession? What can be done about it? In asking and offering answers to these questions, we address a topic that is explored extensively in other organizational sectors, such as government and business, but less so in academia. This topic is especially timely. As Berube (1996) points out, although public criticism of American higher education is not new, it has reached a fever pitch in last decade. Corporate America finds troublesome a professional ethic and sense of independence of professionals that makes them resistant to the bottom line. Other segments of society are concerned about rising costs of higher education and accountability of professors with respect to teaching loads and availability to students (Schuster & Bowen, 1985). The same cultural climate that breeds distrust of tenured faculty as professionals also breeds distrust of politicians, lawyers, journalists, and health care professionals (Berube, 1996). There is a need to examine how moral learning occurs in organizations, especially how obligations and responsibilities to public as well as to fellow professionals are learned, and how organizations respond when individual members breach ethical boundaries. Though organizations differ greatly and generalizations about them are therefore complex, it is reasonable to begin to understand ethics failure by constructing a typology of ethics failure in academia. Moral Nature, Professionalism, and Learning in Academic Organizations The Nature of a Profession A is defined as an occupation that regulates itself through systematic, required training and collegial discipline; that has a base in technical, specialized knowledge; and that has a service rather than profit orientation, enshrined in a code of ethics (Reader, 1966). Wilson (1942) has suggested six criteria as framework for a profession: (1) prolonged and specialized training, (2) rigorous standards of licensure, (3) competency tests cannot be simply deduced, (4) absence of contractual terms of work (5) limitation upon self-interest of practitioner and an insulation from extraneous matters, (6) positive obligations to and its clientele. But, as Becker (1962) points out, word profession is applied to many groups that wish to flatter themselves, therefore, word refers more to a social symbol that people attach to some occupations and not to others. Professions purport to be self-policing. Self-policing is essential, both to prevent regulation by government or other unrelated agencies and to ensure that members of profession--those who are in best position to govern and regulate and whose livelihood depends on profession--are left with ultimate authority for establishing expectations, evaluating profession's contributions to society, monitoring conduct of members and responding to reports of member misconduct in an effort to protect and constituents it serves. …
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bruhn et al. (2002) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: