Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The discourse of recovery has been co-opted by and pervades many standards of mental health service delivery. I want to consider what this means for mood disorders in a clinical context in which the medical model is the primary approach to treatment. The core concept in recovery discourse is concerned with living well in the presence or absence of mental illness and the many losses that may come in its wake, such as isolation, poverty, unemployment and discrimination (Mental Health Commission 2012). However, the way in which this discourse is enacted in practice could be regarded as more of a fiscal strategy that shifts responsibility from a broader social responsibility and specific mental health service responsibility, to an individual responsibility. Service users are expected to know what they need and take responsibility for their own recovery mostly without the resources required to do this. Arguably, this may be fine for some, but not for those overwhelmed and incapacitated by their experience of mood disorder. Generally, governments fund a medical model of care yet set service standards for a recovery model of care for which there is no funding. In this context, the mental health nursing role is often confined to the provision of custodial care (risk assessment, special observations and seclusion) in the acute phase and risk management and promotion of medication adherence during the subacute phase. This obsession with risk management (Crowe & Carlyle, 2003) is an inevitable consequence of the partial approach to recovery provided by the medical model. Recovery-focused care is difficult to implement in a meaningful way where the medical model dominates. Recovery involves a sense of connectedness, hope and optimism about the future, identity, meaning in life and empowerment (Leamy, Bird, Le Boutillier, Williams, & Slade, 2011). It could be argued that the medical model is the antithesis of this. In relation to mood disorders, the medical model constructs these as a fault within the individual, one which is biological and enduring. The individual is observed and assessed in isolation from the context in which they live, their identity is constructed as “patient” and the expertise for facilitating recovery is situated with the professional. Because mood disorders are constructed as a biological defect, the effect of social and interpersonal stress on how the person functions is largely ignored because this stress cannot be treated with medication or containment. Many mood disorders become recurrent mood disorders because of inadequate treatment and a lack of resources to promote recovery. Current management of a serious mood disorder involves the treatment of an acute episode of mood disturbance (often in an inpatient setting), a period of “stabilization” of symptoms (usually in community mental health services) and then discharge to primary care (services that are not funded to manage serious mental disorders). Most people continue to experience very significant problems including ongoing symptoms and relapses, and significant cognitive and functional impairment that impede recovery. A local example of this is that 37% of service users admitted to inpatient units for a serious mood disorder are readmitted within 12 weeks and a further 7% between 3 and 6 months (Canterbury District Health Board, 2015). This is a high cost for tax payers, governments, services, service users and their families. The everyday clinical reality is incongruent with the rhetoric of a recovery-based approach espoused by services and contributes to relapse, recurrence, readmission and poor quality of life. Recovery needs to be a cooperative process in which service users and mental health nurses work together. The key to this is that mental health nurses need to provide the opportunity for service users to access treatments, including medications, that will promote their recovery. It may be useful to think about this process of moving towards wellness as involving three interconnected components: clinical recovery (treatment of acute mood episodes), functional recovery (return to premorbid level of functioning) and personal recovery (learning to live well with a long-term mental disorder). It is well recognized that in mood disorders, effective clinical recovery is best facilitated by a combination of pharmacological and nonpharmacological interventions. Medication is only one tool that should be made available but it is only as a tool to reduce symptoms, and there are many nonpharmacological interventions that also promote clinical recovery, e.g., behavioural activation (Cuijpers, van Straten, & Warmerdam, 2007). Functional recovery requires a resolution of the effects of the acute episode and the medical treatments experienced and includes interpersonal, cognitive and occupational functioning. There are a number of interventions available for mental health nurses to target functional improvement including cognitive remediation interventions (Veeh, Kopf, Kittel-Schneider, Deckert, & Reif, 2017) and interpersonal interventions (Inder et al., 2015). Personal recovery involves developing the skills to live well and is a very individual process that the consumer can undertake on their own, with peers and family or through disorder-specific psychotherapies. Personal recovery can be contrasted with clinical and functional recovery and refers to the process of individual psychological adaptation to the disorder rather than the reduction of psychiatric symptoms, relapse prevention and addressing functional impairment (Tse et al., 2014). It involves those factors described by Leamy (2011) above that can be facilitated by mental health nursing interventions to ensure that service users have the confidence and skills to initiate their own personal recovery. Mental health services need to stop paying lip service to recovery discourse and develop a service delivery model that situates service users’ recovery needs as central. It is only by addressing service users’ needs for recovery that we will be able to provide effective mental health services. We need to advocate for the funding of services that promote recovery not maintain the status quo.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marie Crowe (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: