This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Relocating World Christianity makes one of the most robust theoretical interventions into scholarship on World Christianity since the field first took shape through the efforts of missiologists and theologians. Without denying the value of existing approaches, this volume makes the case for a wider interdisciplinarity that encompasses history, anthropology, and political science, and draws on recent shifts within these disciplines to overcome what, in the introduction, editors Joel Cabrita and David Maxwell present as World Christianity’s fundamental shortcoming: its excessive privileging of place-bound localities and cultural particularities. The problem is World Christianity’s grounding in area studies assumptions born of what Cabrita and Maxwell describe as Western scholars’ and churches’ postcolonial guilt over European imperialism and its ties to Christian expansion. While acknowledging the value of localized studies, Cabrita and Maxwell argue that World Christianity has so far mostly missed the large-scale connections and worldwide flows that matter not only empirically, but also to many Christians’ own perceptions of themselves as members of a universal body. The dominant tendency of compartmentalizing Christianities, treating them as self-contained units runs the risk of reifying local cultures. It also reflects recent theological emphases on incarnation and inculturation at the expense of longer-standing Christian themes of unity and transcendence—as the volume’s other editor, Emma Wild-Wood, argues in the afterword.The fulsome, learned introduction to this volume will surely become required reading for scholars and students of World Christianity. Among the twelve chapters that follow—all by reputable scholars—readers will find compelling evidence in support of the editors’ main thesis. Those chapters are thoughtfully divided into four thematic sections. The first, titled “Connections and Comparisons,” focuses on the interlocking linkages of Christian communities across different parts of the world. The second, “Locating Knowledge,” emphasizes the importance of place in the construction of knowledge about Christianity. It is hard not to see this section as at odds with the overall thrust of the editorial introduction. Peter Phan’s chapter, for example, emphasizes the necessarily contextualized, indigenized, and inculturated dimensions of Christian faith, though not without also gesturing toward cross-continental theological exchanges. In the third section, titled “Place and Belonging in World Christianity,” chapters are concerned with the multiscalar manifestations of Christianity, equally local and translocal, culturalist and connected, nationalist and networked. The fourth section, “Migration and Diaspora,” returns readers squarely to the global scale, to the transnational conduits and symbols through which Christian communities create and sustain themselves along migratory routes.Readers may find dizzying the multiple scales of focus through which they must pass in proceeding from one chapter, and especially from one section, to the next. But what those multiple scales clarify is that attention to the local is not to be altogether discounted. Why, then, the need to contrast so starkly this volume’s approach with previous approaches? There is an unusually polemical tone to the introduction, for example, when it insinuates that site-specific studies reveal “a fetishistic commitment to regional particularity” (21) and are motivated by “normative” and “ideological” agendas such as postcolonial anxieties and anti-imperial politics. Surely the new paradigm proposed here is not itself value-free or ideologically neutral. Analytical trends change with political currents, and though globalization was very recently regnant, the tide has already shifted with the resurgence of nationalist, antiglobalist sentiment (consider Trumpism and Brexit, for example). This calls into question any suggestion that localized frames are historically contingent and ideologically driven in a way that transnational frames are not.As for the major argument of the editorial introduction, World Christianity scholars would likely contest the characterization of their work as insufficiently attentive to the connective and comparative; indeed, the reason most write of World Christianity and not World Christianities seems precisely to emphasize unity alongside diversity. But even within this volume—particularly in the middle two sections—it is clear that networks mean nothing without nodes. How, then, to draw the line between a fair and a fetishized treatment of the local?My own concern is that an overemphasis on the macro-scale potentially slides too easily into homogenizing and universalizing accounts by licensing avoidance of locally grounded, deeply contextualized, linguistically attuned, and empirically detailed inquiry—so long as one attends to the transnational flows and networks now enjoying analytical currency. Occasionally in the introduction, often in the chapters, and importantly in the book’s subtitle, this volume reveals how the local and the universal complement rather than compete with each other, how variegated Christian communities coexist with global faith networks. This is where the volume is at its best.Where it also shines is in its naming and, through particular chapters, correcting of a secondary set of unexamined biases in World Christianity scholarship: toward Africa, toward Protestantism, and toward triumphalist accounts of Christian growth. In sum, this is a landmark volume that carefully historicizes the field of World Christianity and boldly charts new analytical directions. Specialists will debate whether the critiques of existing scholarship are justified, but there will be no dispute that the critiques, and the proposed corrections, must be taken seriously.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Devaka Premawardhana (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: