The E. coli CRISPR-Cas conundrum: are they functional immune systems or genomic singularities?

The discovery and subsequent characterization and applications of CRISPR-Cas is one of the most fascinating scientific stories from the past two decades. While first identified in Escherichia coli , this microbial workhorse often took a back seat to other bacteria during the early race to detail CRISPR-Cas function as an adaptive immune system. This was not a deliberate slight, but the result of early observations that the CRISPR-Cas systems found in E. coli were not robust phage defense systems as first described in Streptococcus thermophilus . This apparent lack of activity was discovered to result from transcriptional repression by the nucleoid protein H-NS. Despite extensive evidence arguing against such roles, some studies still present E. coli CRISPR-Cas systems in the context of anti-phage and/or anti-plasmid activities. Here, the studies that led to our understanding of its cryptic nature are highlighted, along with ongoing research to uncover potential alternative functions in E. coli .