Key result
Blood lactate alone predicts survival in circulatory shock with ~12% misclassification, unimproved by pyruvate.
Why the study?
The study investigated the extent to which increases in arterial blood lactate and pyruvate serve as measures of oxygen deficit and irreversible injury during shock states.
Does the measurement of lactate, pyruvate, or their derived indices predict survival in patients with circulatory shock?
Observational (n=142)
Does the measurement of lactate, pyruvate, or their derived indices predict survival in patients with circulatory shock?
Arterial lactate alone is a reliable and sensitive predictor of survival in circulatory shock, and the addition of pyruvate or derived indices (L/P ratio, excess lactate) does not improve prognostic accuracy.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Arterial lactate reliably prognosticates shock survival; supports its primacy over pyruvate ratios in future risk models.
The increase in lactate (L) and pyruvate (P) content of arterial blood during experimental and clinical shock states and the extent to which such increases serve as measures of oxygen deficit and irreversible injury were investigated on an empirical basis. A standardized method for production of hemorrhagic shock in the Wistar rat was employed. During a 4-hour bleeding period, oxygen consumption of the rat was reduced to approximately 40% of control value, pH was reduced from 7.39 to 7.08, and a concurrent increase in L from 0.80 to 6.06 m m and in P from 0.07 to 0.18 m m were observed. Cumulative oxygen debt correlated with log L (r = 0.50; P < 0.0005) and both were significantly related to survival. Correlation of cumulative oxygen debt and survival, both with P and with computed values of the lactate pyruvate ratio (L/P) and excess lactate (XL), were of no higher magnitude. Partial correlation analysis demonstrated that neither the measurement of P nor the computation of L/P or XL improved predictability. In 142 patients who presented with clinical manifestation of circulatory shock and of whom 62 survived and 80 died, the best empirical discrimination between survivors and those who died was provided by measurement of L, which failed only 11% of the time. This was confirmed by discriminant function analysis in which the percentage probability of misclassification based on L was 12% whereas this probability increased to 21% with L/P and 19% with XL. The combination of XL and L/P with L failed to improve discrimination. In this series of patients, L served as a sensitive predictor; as L increased from 2.1 to 8.0 m m , the estimated probability of survival decreased from 90 to 10%. These studies corroborate that L alone serves as a reliable indicator, but neither the measurement of P nor the computation of L/P or XL was shown to improve either the reliability of L as a measure of cumulative oxygen debt or its value as a prognosticator of survival during shock states.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Weil et al. (1970) conducted an observational in Circulatory shock (n=142). Blood lactate measurement vs. Pyruvate, lactate/pyruvate ratio, and excess lactate was evaluated on Probability of misclassification for survival. Blood lactate alone was a reliable predictor of survival in circulatory shock, and neither pyruvate nor lactate/pyruvate ratio improved predictability.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: