Key result
Integrated Hip Fracture Bundled Care Programme linked to a 5-day shorter community hospital stay.
Why the study?
With a rising incidence and economic burden of geriatric hip fractures in Singapore, the Ministry of Health trialled a bundled payment model covering acute hospital treatment and community hospital rehabilitation, but its clinical outcomes needed objective evaluation.
Does a bundled payment model improve care efficiency and outcomes in elderly patients with surgically treated hip fractures?
Cohort (n=703)
Yes
Does a bundled payment model improve care efficiency and outcomes in elderly patients with surgically treated hip fractures?
A bundled payment model for geriatric hip fractures reduced community hospital length of stay and improved rehabilitation efficiency without compromising clinical outcomes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Bundled hip fracture care was associated with shorter community hospital stays without safety signals; leaves open efficacy in randomized evaluations.
INTRODUCTION Singapore is a developed country with an estimated population of 5.7 million people that are served by eight public hospitals. Over 600 cases of elderly hip fractures are treated annually at Tan Tock Seng hospital, and this accounts for a quarter of the total geriatric hip fractures nationwide. In our ageing population, the number of hip fractures has been increasing steadily at a rate of 3%–5% per annum. It is extrapolated that the incidence of hip fractures will reach 9,000 cases per annum in Singapore by 2050.[1] With each case of hip fracture presently costing SGD 13,313.81 on average, the economic burden of hip fracture may reach SGD 120 million by 2050.[2] In the first quarter of 2016, the Singapore Ministry of Health trialled a bundled payment model on surgically managed geriatric hip fractures. This was based on diagnosis-related group codes for hip arthroplasty and internal fixation for hip fractures. Each patient case, from treatment at an acute hospital (AH) to rehabilitation in a community hospital (CH), would be reimbursed a fixed amount from the government to cover the cost of treatment within 12 days of hospitalisation in AH and 32 days of rehabilitation in CH. Any unplanned readmission within 30 days from CH to AH would be considered part of the original care episode, thereby negating cost savings from other care episodes. This new model included only patients who were aged 60 years and above, underwent surgery for hip fractures and had postoperative rehabilitation in a partner CH. The aim of this study was to objectively evaluate the clinical outcomes of the Integrated Hip Fracture Bundled Care Programme (IHFBCP) with several new implementations. We hypothesised that IHFBCP was able to continue to provide the same, if not better, level of care and rehabilitation for patients with geriatric hip fractures despite a reduction in overall length of stay (LOS), without increasing morbidity and mortality. METHODS A thorough rapid improvement event was conducted from November 2016 to May 2017, several months before the implementation of IHFBCP involving all stakeholders (clinicians in AH and CH, administrative leadership, finance and allied health). Table 1 shows a summary of the objectives and the action plan implemented to achieve the goals. IHFBCP was the result of the improved hip fracture clinical pathway across AH and CH.Table 1: Objectives and interventions of IHFBCP.This study was a retrospective review of prospectively collected data from the hip fracture registry in a single tertiary healthcare institution. The patients were divided into two groups, before and after implementation of IHFBCP. Eligible patients in the control group were included from 1 November 2015 to 1 November 2016 under the Integrated Hip Fracture Care Pathway (IHFCP), whereas patients in the IHFBCP group were included from 1 June 2017 to 1 June 2018. The inclusion criteria were surgically treated hip fracture patients who were above 60 years of age and transferred to either one of the two partnering CHs. The surgical procedures for hip fractures included surgical fixations, hemiarthroplasty and total hip arthroplasty. We excluded the following hip fracture patients: (a) those treated non-operatively; (b) those with other concomitant fractures in other regions; and (c) those with pathological, subtrochanteric or bilateral hip fractures. These inclusion and exclusion criteria were applied to the control group to obtain a close match. The parameters collected included patient demographics such as age and gender, comorbidity burden using Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI), site and type of hip fracture, type of surgery performed and discharge destinations of CH (Ang Mo Kio Community Hospital or Renci Community Hospital). The primary outcome measures were LOS in both AH and CH, readmission rate within 30 days after transfer to CH, 90-day mortality rate and proportion of patients transferred to the two partnering CHs. We also evaluated the functional outcome using the modified Barthel index (MBI) at two points (before transfer to CH and before discharge to the community) and the rehabilitation efficiency in CH (rate of functional recovery during rehabilitation). The rehabilitation efficiency was calculated as follows:[3] Rehabilitation efficiency = (MBI before discharge – initial MBI upon transfer to CH) ÷ LOS (days). Chi-square test or Fisher’s exact test was used for categorical variables, while the t-test or Wilcoxon rank-sum test was used for continuous variables. All P values were two sided. A P value < 0.05 was considered to be statistically significant. Statistical analysis was performed using Stata version 13.1 (StataCorp LP, College Station, TX, USA). The study was approved by National Healthcare Group Domain Specific Review Board (approval no. 2018/00314). RESULTS Comparison of patient demographics and characteristics is shown in Table 2. During the study period, a total of 703 patients who met the inclusion and exclusion criteria were included in the study. There were 361 patients in the control group and 342 patients in the IHFBCP group. The mean age of the control and IHFBCP groups was 80.02 ± 7.76 years and 79.27 ± 8.02 years, respectively. There were 257 female patients (71.19%) in the control group and 255 female patients (74.56%) in the IHFBCP group. There were no statistical differences in age, gender, CCI, discharge destination of CH, and sides and types of hip fracture. Difference in the type of surgery performed (fixations vs. replacements) was found in this study, with a higher proportion of osteosynthesis (203 cases, 56.23%) in the control group and a higher proportion of arthroplasty (179 cases, 52.34%) in the IHFBCP group. This was statistically significant with a P value of 0.023.Table 2: Demographics and characteristics of control and IHFBCP groups.Comparison of primary and secondary outcomes between the control group and the IHFBCP group is shown in Table 3. In terms of primary outcomes, there was no difference in the median LOS in AH (control: 7.9 days vs. IHFBCP: 7.8 days, P = 0.870). On the other hand, there was a marked reduction of median LOS in CH from 30 days to 25 days after the implementation of IHFBCP, which was statistically significant (P < 0.001). There was also an improvement in readmission rate from 11.36% (41/361) to 7.31% (25/342) after starting IHFBCP, although it trended towards statistical significance (P = 0.066). The overall mortality rate within 90 days from the date of admission also showed a positive trend with an overall reduction from 1.94% (7/361) to 0.58% (2/342). Median MBI for hip fracture patients upon transfer to CH was 56 in the control group and 52 in the IHFBCP group. Before discharge from CH, the MBI was remeasured (control: 70 vs. IHFBCP: 72, P = 0.406). There was no significant difference in functional outcomes between the two groups before discharge from CH. However, the IHFBCP group had a significantly higher rehabilitation efficiency of 0.70 compared to 0.47 in the control group (P < 0.001). In addition, with the implementation of IHFBCP, there was a significant increment in the proportion of surgically treated hip fracture patients transferred to the two partnering CHs compared to other stepdown care facilities (P = 0.007).Table 3: Primary and secondary outcomes in the control and IHFBCP groups.DISCUSSION In the United States, the Bundled Payments for Care Improvement (BPCI) initiatives designed payment models that included both financial and performance accountability for episodes of care with the aim of higher quality and more coordinated care at a lower cost.[4] Several studies have assessed the impact of bundled payment models for orthopaedic-related procedures in terms of LOS, readmission, cost-effectiveness and quality of care, and suggested that this model can serve as a foundation to implement patient care pathways that ultimately provide comprehensive and coordinated patient care at lower costs, thereby benefitting both the patient and the healthcare system.[5-7] In total joint arthroplasty, bundled payment models have been shown to reduce cost while maintaining satisfactory outcomes.[8,9] Although these models have yet to be tested exclusively on more complex patient groups such as elderly hip fracture patients with multiple comorbidities, it could well be the potential solution to rising healthcare cost, as demonstrated in recent studies on joint replacements performed for hip fractures.[10-13] Geriatric hip fracture care requires a multidisciplinary, patient-centric and outcome-driven care model that must be coordinated seamlessly across different care settings.[14] In a study by Fisher et al., the authors found that more inpatient-based and specialist-oriented patterns of practice contributed to higher regional healthcare spending. The quality of care or access of care also did not appear to be better with higher healthcare expenditure.[15] Thus, more expensive healthcare did not necessarily translate to higher quality of care. With the inclusion of the care in CH into a single-episode medical reimbursement under IHFBCP, we took the opportunity to further improve, streamline and coordinate care delivery from AH to CH for this group of patients. With similar patient demographics before and after IHFBCP, this study demonstrated that the findings and observed differences were due to effective delivery of geriatric hip fracture care in IHFBCP. With IHFBCP, the patient would be reimbursed a fixed amount for the entire treatment in AH and rehabilitation in CH, regardless of the resources utilised and LOS. This amount would need to cover the treatment of any complications and unplanned readmissions, which was a major disincentive as they were not reimbursed separately. Studies had shown that the LOS was a strong predictor of readmission and morbidity in orthopaedic patients.[16,17] On average, patients spent about three-quarters of their entire hospitalisation in CHs. After IHFBCP was started, a significant reduction in LOS in CH was observed with a much smaller decrease in LOS in AH, although it was not statistically significant. The lower overall LOS for hip fracture patients potentially resulted in cost savings. Analysing the differences in LOS in AH and CH after IHFBCP was started, we noted that there was no significant decrease in LOS in AH. Our established integrated hip fracture clinical pathway was already efficient at providing good-quality care from preoperative medical optimisation, expedited hip fracture surgery, postoperative care to initiation of rehabilitation. The LOS in CH showed a significant decrease after IHFBCP was started. This was the result of a multi-step action plan that is outlined in Table 1, which addresses major obstacles for earlier and safer discharge of the patient back to the community. Quality of care for geriatric patients should always be the utmost priority in the planning of any new pathway, as it is the key to attain positive outcomes.[18] Short-term mortality and unplanned readmissions were suggestive of insufficient medical care before discharge. Readmissions were proven to be costly, as each readmission took up about 20%–30% of the total spending per bundled payment episode.[13] Postoperatively, the management of other medical problems was also optimised to avoid unnecessary readmissions to AH. After the implementation of IHFBCP, we noted that both 30-day readmission rate and 90-day mortality rate showed a favourable trend, although this was not statistically significant. This result was comparable to, if not better than, the readmission rates reported by Lott et al.,[13] which decreased from 29.5% to 18.2%, and Bair et al.,[19] who reported an all-cause 30-day readmission rate of 11.5% after the bundled payment initiative. This was evidence that despite shorter overall LOS, IHFBCP was able to deliver effective geriatric hip fracture care without increasing mortality and readmissions. As the care of the geriatric hip fracture patients transited from IHFCP to IHFBCP, we found that the percentage of hip arthroplasty also increased. Lott et al. reported decreased cost of care in hip fracture patients who underwent arthroplasty under the BPCI initiatives.[12] While we acknowledge that hip prosthesis may be more costly than the implants for fracture fixation, we are uncertain how this may impact the final cost savings from reduction in LOS. This will require a more thorough cost-utilisation analysis. In the analysis of rehabilitation outcomes, we noted that the final MBI on discharge in IHFBCP was similar to that under IHFCP. This favourable outcome was further supported by the significant improvement in rehabilitation efficiency in the IHFBCP group. The combination of standardised rehabilitation protocols and goals, standardised discharge functional criteria, early identification of problems upon discharge back to the community, recruitment of necessary community support services and the continuation of community rehabilitation allowed for earlier return to home environment without sacrificing functional recovery. Young et al. found that the functional recovery patterns in elderly hip fracture patients were heterogeneous and advocated healthcare professionals to consider individual recovery trajectories to foster functional independence.[20] The needs of each patient differed, and therefore, it was necessary to individualise the usage of community resources and rehabilitation support after the patient was discharged from CH. There were several limitations to our study. Firstly, a single outcome could not be attributed to a single intervention, as there were multiple action plans in IHFBCP and the outcomes were analysed collectively. Secondly, the significantly higher proportion of arthroplasty surgery in IHFBCP could result in bias. Thirdly, we could not analyse the exact cost savings after the implementation of IHFBCP and potential cost savings were estimated from reduction in overall LOS alone. Lastly, the longer-term trends in cost savings, LOS, mortality and readmission trends could not be observed in this study. In conclusion, with the evolution of IHFCP to into IHFBCP, geriatric hip fracture care was effectively delivered with the same quality of care and achieved similar functional outcomes without observed short-term mortality and readmissions. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chan et al. (2024) conducted a cohort in Geriatric hip fractures (n=703). Integrated Hip Fracture Bundled Care Programme (IHFBCP) vs. Integrated Hip Fracture Care Pathway (IHFCP) was evaluated on Median length of stay in community hospital (days) (p=<0.001). The Integrated Hip Fracture Bundled Care Programme reduced median length of stay in community hospitals from 30 to 25 days without increasing readmissions or mortality.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: