Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Recently I stumbled across a thought-provoking athletic booster letter from my undergraduate alma mater. The mailer was addressed "Dear Seminole" and asked that I pledge money to my Tallahassee "tribe." I understood the request, of course, as constitutive rhetoric shared between Florida State University and me—discourse meant to unite collegiate and personal identities into a collective, a so-called "tribe."1 Truly, though, I am not part of a Native nation or society. In fact the concept of assuming Native culture and subsequently eclipsing it with a corporeal desire for championship football and top-notch Nike athletic apparel concerns me as a cultural critic. Likewise the cultural materialism of the Florida State Seminole embarrasses me as a graduate of an institution the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights recently argued "encourages biases and prejudices that have a negative effect on contemporary Indian people... (and) blocks genuine understanding of contemporary Native people as fellow Americans."2 The dual identities of Florida State Seminole and cultural critic present an intriguing conundrum, a tension that drives my interest in examining what I deem the "mascotting" of Native America. On the one hand, I carry with me a so-called misrepresented identity, a Seminole persona I do not understand but apparently assume through attending football games and hanging framed parchment on my wall. On the other hand, without a lived experience—replete with cultural understanding, prejudicial suffering, and a sense of heritage—how can Florida State University actually refer to me in good faith as "Dear Seminole?" The identity vertigo leads to a number of questions. Why do universities insist on employing Native mascots? Why are American Indians upset at collegiate appropriations of their culture? Most importantly for this study, how does the appropriation of tribal identity affect Indigenous peoples? These questions have plagued both sides of the mascot debate since 1968 when the National Congress of American Indians "began a campaign to address native [End Page 605] stereotypes found in sports and media."3 Subsequently the past thirty years have witnessed student protests and Natives challenging the authority of the "ivory" towers (for example, University of Illinois, Florida State University, University of North Dakota); universities accommodating antimascot activists by changing their mascots (for example, Stanford University, St. John's University, Syracuse University); and university strategies of control, arguing for the Native as a symbol rather than a mascot. Ironically, for all the social and political activity surrounding the mascot controversy, "Native American mascots remain understudied, too often taken for granted, and rarely questioned by scholars and citizens alike."4 Indigenous groups, along with cultural studies scholars, view the Native mascots as hegemonic devices—commodification tools—that advance a contemporary manifest destiny by marketing Native culture as Euramerican identity.5 Kent Ono and Derek Buescher, for instance, write that "Euro-American culture has made a habit of appropriating, and redefining what is 'distinctive' and constitutive of Native Americans. This strategy of appropriation relies on culturally specific views of ownership and property."6 According to this viewpoint the university consumes and reconfigures Native experiences, a practice institutionally supported by the long history of European and Euramerican prejudices against Indigenous peoples: from the violence of "Columbian contact" and the brutality of the Trail of Tears, to the trampling of Indigenous rights evident in present policies to deny the American Indian community repatriation and reparation. Such consumption harkens back to the long-standing tradition of white hegemonic control over Native identity.7 American Indians and Native social movements have not stood by idly as universities, in particular, have asserted their dominance through appropriating Native images. The American Indian Movement (AIM), the Conference on the Elimination of Racist Mascots, and several smaller, grassroots protest cells have come out against universities and professional sports teams alike, insisting that their voices be heard. Bill Means of AIM helped organize the now famous 1991 World Series protests of the Atlanta Braves. During a game against the...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jason Edward Black (2002) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: