Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Transparency and diversity to advance legal-scientific communicationWe are honoured to provide this opening editorial for the special issue on 'Rethinking Scientific Communication in Courts'. 1 The four articles within this special issue contribute to ongoing international discussions and innovations about improving the ways in which scientific knowledge is conveyed for legal users [1-3]. 2 They arose from a conference of the same name held at the Australian National University in November 2023. 3 The importance of clear and epistemically modest scientific communication for the administration of justice, particularly the administration of criminal justice, cannot be understated.As Michael Kirby AC CMG has observed, 'human justice is always prone to error and mistaken outcomes ' [4].Whilst the possibility of error or mistake is not limited to cases involving expert evidence, expert evidence is an area where courts are particularly vulnerable to error.The hard lesson of mounting Royal and Special Commissions is that the risks of wrongful convictions are real where the limitations of expert evidence are not appreciated, either by the courts, or by the experts themselves.Accordingly, the conference was convened in recognition of the particular challenges that modern courts face when dealing with expert evidence.There has been an exponential growth in scientific research in many forensic areas.As the conference organisers recognised, much of this research is of uneven quality and there is often a lack of transparency in the research, which is necessary for the accurate assessment of its reliability.There are two themes which emerged in the conference and which feature in the four articles.The first is the strength of disciplinary diversity, in particular, the importance of drawing upon the expertise of a range of experts in different disciplines in creating, compiling and communicating expert evidence.As the philosopher of science Naomi Orsekes has observed, this kind of intellectual diversity strengthens knowledge generation processes, including by allowing for the interrogation of assumptions that may otherwise slip through unnoticed and produce error.In particular, she notes: 'In diversity there is epistemic strength [5].'In this spirit, the special issue's authors come from a variety of fields, including forensic science, law, science policy and education, psychology, metaresearch, systematic review methods, and beyond [6][7][8][9].The authors rely on that diverse expertise to provide new ideas and solutions for the challenges of communicating science in legal contexts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chin et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: