Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The study to be considered here was undertaken because of the clinical impression that a significant percentage of patients with portal venous congestion due to an extrahepatic portal obstruction are reported by the roentgenologist as having a duodenal deformity. Such a finding might be misinterpreted as a sign of duodenal ulcer, especially if the patient has presented with upper gastrointestinal bleeding and if esophagogastric varices are not demonstrable at the time of the roentgen examination. Even if varices are visualized, confusion about the source of the bleeding can occur. It is generally accepted that patients with hepatic cirrhosis have a 15 to 20 per cent incidence of duodenal ulceration (1). Hence, the clinician is not surprised when the radiologist reports esophagogastric varices and duodenal ulcer in the same case. In reviewing the records of 63 cases of portal congestion due to extrahepatic obstruction studied by Hallenbeck and Adson (2), it was noted that the roentgenologist reported a deformity of the duodenum in 8 instances (13 per cent). None of the 8 patients had a history suggestive of duodenal ulcer, and their subsequent course revealed nothing to substantiate such a diagnosis. Within a week of their gastrointestinal examination, 4 of the 8 underwent surgical procedures which revealed no abnormalities of the duodenum. Definite extrahepatic obstructions were demonstrated in all 8, either at surgery or by portal venography. A review of the literature, including Liebowitz' (3) comprehensive text on the subject of portal hypertension, revealed no report of duodenal deformity associated with extrahepatic portal obstruction. Guiotto and Miceli (4) published a case in which a patient with extrahepatic portal obstruction was found to have an actively bleeding duodenal ulcer. In none of the 63 cases we have studied was there an associated duodenal ulcer, and we do not believe there is a correlation between the presence of such an ulcer and extrahepatic portal obstruction, as is commonly noted between duodenal ulcer and hepatic cirrhosis. Material Our study began with 63 cases seen by Hallenbeck and Adson from 1951 to 1960. As previously mentioned, in 8 of the 63 patients a duodenal deformity was reported by the roentgenologist. Six of this group were males and 7 of the 8 were less than thirty years of age. During the last year 2 additional patients with extrahepatic portal obstruction were seen, and in both instances duodenal deformities were observed roentgenologically. In one of these, a fourteen-year-old girl, the duodenal cap was inspected at operation and no evidence of an ulcer was found. The other patient, a twenty-seven-year-old man, has had no symptoms suggestive of peptic ulcer. In this group of 10 patients, the cause of the extrahepatic portal obstruction was thrombosis of the portal vein in 7 and cavernous transformation of the veins of the porta hepatis in the others.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Olson et al. (1963) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: