Key result
Most QCA and angio-FFR programs estimate minimum lumen diameter within ~0.1 mm of true values.
Why the study?
Do different QCA and angio-based FFR programs accurately and precisely measure minimum lumen diameter compared to true values in phantom models?
Do different QCA and angio-based FFR programs accurately and precisely measure minimum lumen diameter compared to true values in phantom models?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Significant variations in minimum lumen diameter measurements exist among commercially available QCA and angio-based FFR programs, which may impact diagnostic performance and clinical decisions.
Background Accurate dimensional measurements are critical for quantitative coronary angiography (QCA) and serve as the first step in angiography‐based fractional flow reserve (FFR) calculations. Aims To compare minimum lumen diameter (MLD) measurements across multiple QCA or anigo‐based FFR software programs using phantom models. Methods Fourteen QCA and angio‐based FFR programs were evaluated using six plexiglass phantoms, each containing three sequential bifurcations with known true values for the MLD of the proximal main, distal main, and side branch vessels. The accuracy and precision of MLD measurements were assessed by comparing software‐measured values with true values across 54 MLD measurement points. No manual correction of the vessel contour was performed. The results of the 14 programs were reported anonymously. Results The mean differences between the measured and true values were small (< 0.1 mm), however, in two angio‐based FFR programs, the discrepancies were large (> 0.3 mm). The standard deviations of the differences were approximately 0.1 mm, except in one angio‐based FFR program, where it exceeded 0.3 mm. Differences from true values were more pronounced in small (≦ 0.7 mm) compared to large (> 0.7 mm) true MLDs. The reproducibility of measurements was high (Pearson's correlation coefficient > 0.98) across all programs. Conclusion Variations in MLD measurements were observed among different QCA and angio‐based FFR programs. These variations may influence diagnostic performance and can seriously impact decisions made solely using angio‐based FFR.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tobe et al. (2025) studied this question. QCA and angio-based FFR software programs vs. True values from phantom models was evaluated on Minimum lumen diameter (MLD) measurements accuracy and precision. Mean differences between measured and true minimum lumen diameter values were generally <0.1 mm across 14 QCA and angio-based FFR programs, though two programs showed discrepancies >0.3 mm.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: